SPECIALA strategy not making much sense
Critics and stakeholders say wider, practical views have not been drafted into the proposed health policy.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
04 Apr 2011, 10:02 AM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 04:35 PM
Nurul Islam Hasib
bdnews24.com senior correspondent
Dhaka, Apr 4 (bdnews24.com)—No fewer than 110,000 people, who stay just five hours' drive from capital Dhaka, never see a qualified doctor at their locality, say experts.
The health ministry has finalised draft of a national health policy after two years of bickering that still cannot ensure a doctor for those people of Chatolpur, Goalnagar and Bhulaput village under Brahmanbaria, a district in Bangladesh's heartland.
Experts say ensuring healthcare access for every citizen remains a challenge in Bangladesh that the draft policy, full of strategies, fails to focus on.
Nearly 20 percent people have access to government health, according to the ministry. Health-right activists, however, put the number below 10 percent, though the country has robust healthcare structure.
But slack management cripples health services and even allows workers to dodge their works, said Farida Akhter, a health-right activist.
Health minister AFM Ruhal Haque has said they prepared the draft pooling public as well as different stakeholders' opinions.
"Opinions have been elicited through online feedbacks and meetings at different divisional headquarters," he said.
In reality, though, critics say, those views did not find a way in the final draft.
bdnews24.com has obtained a document containing those public opinions where some pragmatic steps were suggested; but surprisingly, none was integrated in the final draft.
Akhter, also joint convenor of Swasthya Andolon (Health Movement), said she was surprised that their concerns and suggestions were kept out of the draft.
"We have given many suggestions, but those were not included in the final draft," she told bdnews24.com.
She suspects that the views of the donors were given priority, not those of Bangladeshis. Bangladesh's reliance on international aid is now down to only 2 percent of its annual development budget.
According to Akhter, this policy simply cannot guarantee access to all.
"There are many issues that need to be addressed to streamline the ailing healthcare system in Bangladesh. But first of all, we need to ensure access for all," said Dr Zafarullah Chowdhury, trustee of Gonoshasthaya Public Charitable Trust.
So, he said, steps should be taken. "If we cannot do that, then what is the point of having a health policy in Bangladesh in the first place?"
"Doctors do not stay in their workplace. So there must be a system that will keep them there, whether its incentives or stricter rules."
In the absence of qualified doctors, quacks also known as village doctors dominate rural health. Several studies show they mainly do malpractice, but the proposed health policy does not keep a provision to monitor or check such practices.
'NOT PUT TOGETHER'
In finalising the draft, the health ministry pooled public opinions through meetings of stakeholders at Barisal, Khulna, Chattaganj, Sylhet and Rangpur.
A meeting was also organised at the prime minister's office in the presence of a World Bank expert team.
There were some common realistic suggestions coming from those meetings, but the final draft had accommodated not a single one.
For instance, suggestions were there for incentives to healthcare staff working in hard-to-reach areas to encourage the doctors and others to hang in their workplace.
The participants also recommended keeping provision for mandatory internship for medical graduates at rural hospitals apart from medical college hospitals which will orient them with rural health system early in their career.
Redresses for malpractices were also recommended during those meetings.
Stakeholders also suggested introducing 'behavioural science' in medical curriculum to narrow down the gap between patients and doctors.
Health minister, without answering why such public opinions were not included in the policy, told journalists to put forward some written suggestions.
"We will include your suggestions," he told journalists on March 30, with the draft being finalised a month and a half earlier.
He, however, said the government will introduce insurance for poor people, if necessary.
"People do not get confidence in going to hospitals, though those are free. They think it will cost money. If we can give them a card, they will get assurance," he said.
However, a member of the national committee formed to finalise the draft health policy told bdnews24.com that the ministry had to change committees thrice to finalise a draft in the last two years due to wrangling between health ministry and Bangladesh Medical Association (BMA), the national association of the doctors.
"One committee elicited public opinions while another finalised the draft keeping those opinions aside," he said, requesting anonymity.
Whatever the fact is, government healthcare will remain elusive for many people like those on Chatolpur, Goalnagar and Bhulaput villages for many more years.
bdnews24.com/nih/bd/1550h