November 20, 2026

Green Climate Fund a big hurdle

A global climate deal is paramount for the success of COP17 before the talks close by the week's end, writes Syed Talat Kamal from Durban

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 05 Dec 2011, 02:49 PM

Updated : 10 Aug 2022, 05:54 PM

Sayed Talat Kamal from Durban, South Africa Durban, Dec 5 (bdnews24.com) — The two hurdles that 194 members of the UN climate convention need to resolve at Durban's climate summit before it concludes on December 9, are an agreement on the extension of the Kyoto Protocol and establishment of the UN Green Climate Fund — which essentially means everything might be at risk of collapse. In recent developments the US, Saudi Arabia and Alba bloc, which include Bolivia, Cuba and Venezuela, have joined to raise concerns about the UN Green Climate Fund saying that they cannot accept the draft plan. The UN Green Climate Fund is one of the key proposals that delegates are working to include in a package to fight global warming. Once approved and established, the fund is expected to deliver over US$ 100 billion a year as aid for developing countries, most vulnerable to climate change, pay for programmes to adapt to climate change and reduce their own green house gas emissions. Climate change is a result of greenhouse gases trapping the sun's heat in the earth's atmosphere. The trapped heat raises global temperatures, which in turn trigger changes in weather conditions, leading to stronger and more frequent cyclones and floods, rising seas, drought, erosion and increased salinity. It is widely accepted that a rise of global temperatures over 2 degrees Celsius would cause irreversible climate change. Global studies, endorsed by the UN and the scientific community indicate that in order to arrest the temperature rise within 1.5 degrees, global emissions must reduced to 40 percent of what they were in 1990 by the year 2020 and to 95 percent of 1990-levels by 2050. Furthermore emissions must not peak after 2015. Reservations follow comments from China and Brazil at the conference that indicate that they are unlikely to sign a new deal unless industrial nations make a commitment on reducing emissions under the Kyoto Protocol which expires at the end of 2012. The US delegation leader, Jonathan Pershing, has raised concerns that the plan contained "errors and inconsistencies." Ilana Solomon, of Action Aid USA, confirmed that the draft document on the Green Climate Fund was deemed imperfect by all participating countries, adding that several nations have also raised issues about how the fund would be managed. "They wanted a closer relationship between the fund and the [summit], as well as how the private sector would get involved," she said. Moreover there were also concerns raised at the World Bank's involvement in managing the funds, particularly because the organisation had a history of investing in dirty climate projects. Nezir Sinani, of the Institute of Development in Kosovo, has said that he had met many delegates from across the world with the same story "the World Bank was funding unsustainable operations that are damaging the environment." Under the circumstances, he argues, "The Green Climate Fund should not be given to the World Bank." Suspicions are rife with regard to the private sector managing the funds as well. On one side of the street across the International Conference Centre (ICC), where the talks are being held in Durban, stands a 2m tall inflatable octopus with tentacles clinging to climate fund placards. The octopus represents greedy multinational conglomerates putting their hands in the Green Climate Fund pot. Despite opposing views among delegates with regard to the fund, all the delegates agree, however, said Solomon, that the green fund should be resolved in Durban. As delegates debate the details of an agreement, whose text is already five times as long as the agreement from last year's meeting in Cancun, Kelly Dent of Oxfam has warned the debate over funding could not be allowed to go on much longer. "We need money in the (Green Climate) fund; we need budgetary action now." Talks seem suspended as India, China and the US stand united against the EU's timeline for talks for drawing up a new climate treaty, which would extend the Koyoto Protocol to limit greenhouse gas emissions further. So far the 27-nation bloc has done the most to limit carbon dioxide fumes since the Kyoto protocol was signed in 1997. However, the EU has now said that it would sign on to a second commitment period of the protocol on condition that at least all the world's major emitters of greenhouse gases commit themselves to a new legally binding treaty to curb emissions in Durban. The US, EU, Japan, Russia, Canada, and Australia are seeking a treaty that goes beyond the Kyoto restrictions and not impose a binding climate pact on just rich countries but also major greenhouse emitters, effectively suggesting caps on China, India and Brazil too. Currently only the EU, Norway, Switzerland, Australia and New Zealand have voiced their intensions for a second Kyoto period. However, those economies only account for 26 precent of global emissions - which is too small for any real impact on reversing climate change and limiting temperature increases to the internationally agreed restriction of 2 degree Celsius. On the other hand China alone accounted for 24 percent, the US for a little under 20 percent and India a little over 5 percent - which together accounts for almost half of global emissions. Notably major emerging economies and other developing countries already emit more that half of current carbon emissions, and within 20 years are projected to account for as much as two-thirds. Indian government official and delegation head, JM Mauskar, has dismissed any notions of legally binding greenhouse restrictions, however, claiming that "our objective in these negotiations is not to launch a process for a new climate treaty… this is not what these current negotiations are about." The ability to arrive at an agreement is tantamount to successful conclusion of the two-week Durban talks, which is scheduled to finish this Friday, and it is feared that prolonged opposing positions could kill any chance for a binding deal during COP17. There is a glimmer of hope, however, that the talks may not actually collapse as, for the first time, China, which is the biggest emitter by far among emerging economies, has hinted at accepting legal obligations to cut its emissions under a new international framework; previously China had insisted on exemption as a "developing" country. bdnews24.com/stk/ta/bd/2041h
Related Stories