SEC defies its own ban
The regulators shock the market as they let two companies raise a thousand crore through book building
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
22 Jan 2011, 01:36 PM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 04:14 PM
Dhaka Jan 22 (bdnews24.com)—The SEC finally woke up to the dangers of book building in the current market conditions banning the pricing method on Thursday but shocked the edgy market by giving the go-ahead to two companies which will raise nearly a thousand crore at exorbitantly high premiums.
Despite having week "balance sheets", these two companies—with staggering PE ratios of 50 and 70—will be allowed to sell their stocks at "ridiculously" high rates.
Under the amended Book Building Rules that make it possible to obtain prices similar to much-criticised direct listing, the SEC cleared the IPOs of M I Cement and Mobil-Jamuna.
And these two were exempted from the book building ban slapped on a day when the DSE lost 600 points in less than six minutes.
M I Cement will raise Tk 335 crores at Tk 111.60 per share of Tk 10 each at a PE Ratio of 50.
The other company, Mobil-Jamuna, will take home Tk 610 crore at Tk 152.40 per share of Tk 10 each at a PE Ratio of 70.
SEC officials say the M I Cement subscription is complete, the lottery has been held and shares allotted. However listing has not taken place as yet.
In the case of Mobil-Jamuna, subscription is complete but lottery or the allotment of shares is yet to be done.
SEC just reacted to warnings of impending "disasters" when it issued the notification suspending book building method.
Under the current market conditions, these shares will lose at least two-thirds of their value immediately upon listing.
"The premium charged is inflated beyond reason at very high PE levels resulting in the poor investor, who subscribed to the IPO, once again being taken for a ride," a top broker said, asking for anonymity.
A formal, and very public, objection to book building method from the DSE president on Thursday.
"Confusions have arisen in the matter of new shares coming through the book-building system. There were problems in fixing prices of new shares," DSE president Shakil Rizvi told the press.
He claimed that most of the 48 companies seeking to get listed through book-building had "weak balance sheets".
"The authorities should look into the issue properly."
Not that bad if done right
Economists, however, say that book building—the market driven price discovery method—has its benefits but the regulators must play its due role.
"There have been cases where overpriced shares debuted in the market, but that may have happened as the regulator has not been cautious enough," says Dr Zaid Bakht of BIDS.
He adds the SEC must ensure the whole process becomes "logical".
Caretaker advisor Mirza Azizul Islam, himself a former SEC chairman, also says that the regulator should rigorously monitor the price discovery process of an IPO.
"They [SEC] should look whether an issue has been overpriced by any coalition between the issuer and institutional investors" he told bdnews24.com.
bdnews24.com/rhn/gna/1930h.