November 20, 2026

Motorola CEO gets 'bonus'

Martyn Warwick, editor-in-chief of telecomTV in London, writes about how fat cats hide their takings Earlier this month I wrote a piece about corporate raider Carl Icahn's bid to be elected to a seat on the board of Motorola and the fact that the company's shareholders are exhibiting increasing signs of disquiet at the levels of remuneration being paid to top executives of the Chicago-headquartered handset manufacturing company.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 22 Mar 2007, 09:18 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:44 PM

Martyn Warwick London, March 22 (bdnews24.com) -- Earlier this month I wrote a piece about corporate raider Carl Icahn's bid to be elected to a seat on the board of Motorola and the fact that the company's shareholders are exhibiting increasing signs of disquiet at the levels of remuneration being paid to top executives of the Chicago-headquartered handset manufacturing company. I took as a prime example of that largesse the rewards paid to Motorola's CEO, Ed Zander. I wrote that although Zander's salary basic salary of US$1.5 million has not risen by a single red cent since he took over as head honcho on January 5, 2004, his a take home pay last year nonetheless climbed to $13.2 million. Part of this immense sum comprised $9.5 million in shares or stock options as well as incidentals such as $351,000 for the personal use of company aircraft and $56,000 for the use of a limousine and a chauffeur. All this information was and is freely available via a Motorola filing that can be accessed on the website of the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Part of that filing stresses that Zander did not receive any annual bonus for last year. Hardly surprising, one might think, given the fact that Motorola's Q4 performance was well below Wall St. expectations, profits were in free fall, products lacked the "oomph" they used to have and shareholders were angry. So I duly reported that despite all the other emoluments Zander was denied a yearly bonus, and there the matter would have rested had not an interested Telecom TV viewer contacted me and pointed me in the direction of the proxy statement Motorola has to file to comply with US federal regulations. Those regulations changed between 2005 and 2006 and Motorola took full advantage of that to disguise the fact that whilst Zander indeed had not been paid an annual "bonus" in the "bonus" line of the company accounts, he was the recipient of $1.27 million in "Non-Equity Incentive Plan Compensation". As William Shakespeare so eloquently put it, "A rose by any other name would smell as sweet." In the US, publicly traded companies must submit every year to the SEC a so-called "proxy statement". In 2005, when Motorola was doing very well, the report included a line recording that the CEO got $3 million as a "Bonus". In this year's statement the "Bonus" line is blank, as Motorola's PR people have been so keen to point out. However, as is often said, the devil is in the detail and so, tucked elsewhere in the small print and copious footnotes is a reference to "cash awards" made under the terms of the "Motorola Incentive Plan". Now, payments through the Incentive Plan are made according to a formula that includes performance targets and other criteria and these formula-based payments can now go into a new category which is, surprise, surprise, "Non-Equity Incentive Plan Compensation". Why? Apparently because they are not "true bonuses" that appear magically from the heavens due to unforeseen circumstances and therefore they don't have to be recorded as such. Neat, eh? So, from now on, Motorola shareholders will have to go through the many appendices and footnotes that litter the annual accounts to find out exactly what the company's senior executives are really earning – and, of course, few of them will. In its defence, the SEC says it changed the regulations to compel companies to disclose discretionary bonus payments, but the change seems to have served only to make it easier to hide things. I wonder what will happen if Icahn does get a seat on the Motorola board? The company's top executives don't want him there, but an increasing number of shareholders do. And one can see why. bdnews24.com/ask/ad/1501 hours
Related Stories