November 21, 2026

Govt losing out on saving certificate sales

Low sales lead government paying out more in interests than the amount it gets from sales, Abdur Rahim Harmachi reports.

Staff Correspondent

bdnews24.com

Published : 15 Apr 2012, 08:03 AM

Updated : 24 Apr 2022, 03:07 PM

Abdur Rahim Harmachi

Chief economics correspondent

Dhaka, Apr 15 (bdnews24.com) -- The government is in tight spot as it had to pay out more as interests than the income from sales of savings instruments in the first eight months of the current fiscal (July to February).

Different types of savings certificate are key instrument for government to mobilise funds for deficit financing.

People have seemingly turned away from investing in this once 'most safe' option. Even an increase in interest on return has failed to woo clients. As a result, the government's target of raising Tk 60 billion through sales of saving certificates to finance the budget deficit for the current fiscal now seems a 'distant dream'.

Finance minister A M A Muhith can not find any reason, but former Bangladesh bank governor Mohammad Farashuddin blamed step to cut tax at source for people to shy away from the government-sponsored savings instruments.

The recent statistics of saving certificate sales in the first eight months of this fiscal show the income from saving certificates is in the red, which means there was apparently no sale of savings instruments during this period.

The earnings from certificate sales have exceeded by the amount the government has to payback as interest, according to latest statistics.

This is the first such example of negative earnings from the sales savings instruments in an eight-month period, officials said.

Sometimes the neat sales can be negative for a month or so, but it was covered by sales in the predeceasing months, they said.

In the same period (July to February) of the previous fiscal (2010-11), the neat sales of savings instruments was Tk 26.13 billion. In the current year, the neat sales stood at a negative Tk 10.81 billion, meaning there was no sale but government had to pay back the amount as interest.

Muhith is dismayed by the scenario, "I do not disturb investors in savings instruments. But can not understand why the sales have gone into negative."

However, former Bangladesh Bank governor Mohammad Farashuddin thinks that the people turned their backs to this mode of investment due to the five percent tax imposed by the government on their earnings from saving certificates.

"Nearly half of the revenue a person earns in the form of interest at the end of the tenure of investment is cut by the government as taxes. Why will he invest in saving certificates then?" Farshuddin posed the question.

"Specially deducting five percent from earnings of pensioners saving certificates is completely illogical and is not acceptable in any way. No country in the world cuts taxes from such savings," he vented.

Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies (BIDS) research director Jayed Bakht told bdnews24.com: "Huge amount of money of the people are stuck in the capital market. When the market was doing good, people have put money there taking their investment from savings instruments."

"However, after the capital market crash, no one is selling shares at a loss and are waiting for opportune moment to recover their investments, if not making profit."

Pointing out that the government is also in a dilemma, Bakht continued, "Since certificates sales are in the negative, the government cannot take loans from here.

"So the government is taking loan from the banking sector triggering high inflation and blocking credit flow to the private sector. This is having adverse effect on the economy."

"It would have been better if the government could raise funds through sales of saving certificates instead of taking loans from banking sector," Bakht adds.

While presenting the budget for 2011-12 fiscal in the parliament on June 9 last year, finance minister A M A Muhith has slashed deducting tax at source from 10 percent to five percent on earnings from saving instruments.

The interest rate was also raised by 1 to 1.5 percentage point after the budget was passed.

Since the sales did not go up still, interests were further increased on Mar 1. It was raised by 1.38 to 3 percentage point.

Records of sales of saving certificate for March is not available. However, an official of the National Savings Directorate told bdnews24.com on condition of anonymity: "Sales have not gone up even after increasing the interest rates. Maybe it will go up in the future."

bdnews24.com/arh/rn/sk/1330h

Related Stories