Sayedee bail ruling on Sunday
This is the seventh time that the defence has approached the tribunal praying for bail of Jamaat leader. Full story, with more quotes
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
21 Jun 2012, 11:43 AM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:55 PM
Dhaka, Jun 21 (bdnews24.com) — The first war crimes tribunal heated up so much on Thursday that the Chairman threatened to throw out prosecution lawyers if they continued to pass comments during cross-examination of their witness.
The stiff warning came during cross-examination of the fifth prosecution against BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury who had allegedly killed Nutan Chandra Singha during the 1971 Liberation War.
Nutan's youngest son Prafulla Ranjan Singha took the stand on Thursday and completed his deposition which was followed by cross-examination by Salauddin Quader's defence counsel.
Nutan Chandra was the founder of Kundeshwari Oushadhalaya, a herbal medicine producer. He also ran a school and college by the same name within the same complex near Chittagong City.
Set up to try crimes against humanity during the 1971 War of Independence, the International Crimes Tribunal-1 indicted the BNP policymaker with 23 war crimes charges.
According to Prafulla's testimony, witnesses had told him how his father Nutan Chandra on Apr 13, 1971, was dragged out of the temple within the Kundeshwari complex and shot there by the BNP policymaker, when then was a 21-year old.
Salauddin Quader, a six-time MP from Chittagong, lived in the nearby Goods Hill which is still owned by his family. His father Fazlul Quader, belonging to a faction of the pro-Pakistan Muslim League, was the Acting President and Speaker of the National Assembly of Pakistan before the war broke out in 1971.
On the day of the incident, Prafulla had been told, Salauddin Quader came to Kundeshwari with a group of Pakistani military personnel and at first interrogated Nutan and left. However, they came back within minutes, apparently at the behest of Salauddin Quader. This time they dragged Nutan out of the temple and shot him.
Even as Nutan writhed in agony on the ground, Salauddin came up close and shot him a few times, according to what Prafulla had heard from witnesses.
Ahsanul Haq, the defence counsel, had suggested that the BNP government gave a substantial amount of money to Kundeshwari initiatives. Prafulla replied, "Not a lot. Only Tk 2.25 million for the school and college as a government grant."
Ahsanul Haq: How about the Ershad government.
Prafulla: Yes. Tk 100,000 for the biology department at the Kundeshwari College.
Ahsanul Haq: But this government has not given you anything.
Prafulla: This Awami League government on Mar 26 (Bangladesh's Independence Day), conferred the Independence Award (Swadhinata Padak) on my father. I took the honorarium of Tk 200,000 on my father's behalf and donated it to the Kundeshwari College.
Ahsanul Haq: This award was given to coax you into testifying against Salauddin Quader Chowdhury.
Prafulla denied the suggestion amid protests from the prosecution. Prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum had stood up to protest the question saying that this demeaned the dignity of national independence.
Prafulla commented indicating Ahsanul Haq and joining with the prosecutors, "His party does not even believe in independence. Why would he care?"
Ahsanul Haq protested loudly saying, "Whose party?"
"Yours," was the answer from the stand. "And which party is that?" Prafulla brazenly replied, "BNP."
The defence counsel became visibly excited and told the witness that he knew very well that the counsel did not belong to any party.
Unable to contain himself, the defence lawyer requested an adjournment. The prosecutors protested as the defence counsel's voice escalated a few notches while he addressed the witness. "Please behave professionally," Prosectur Zead-Al-Malum said.
Tribunal Chairman, Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq, said, "Do sit down for five minutes and rest. Have some water if you need."
The counsel complied but as soon as he had recovered and about to take the podium a junior member of the defence whispered into his ear that a prosecutor had called him, "Beyadob!" (roughly meaning insolent in English)
The counsel brought this to the attention of the tribunal immediately to which the tribunal told the junior that it was his job to keep the senior counsel's temper cool and recounted his experience about how the Chairman himself, when he was a junior lawyer, was expected to contain the temper of his senior.
Apparently Prosecutor Altaf Uddin Ahmed, conducting the case against Jamaat-e-Islami chief Matiur Rahman Nizami, had passed the remark regarding Ahsanul Haq.
He addressed the prosecutors indicating the defence counsel, "He is an aged man and well-respected. You should remember that. All of you are also respected lawyers and you should behave accordingly or we will be compelled to take further steps."
Justice Huq's ultimatum came within minutes after Altaf Uddin raised his voice again when Prafulla had been asked another question.
This time the tribunal chief addressed the chief prosecutor, Ghulam Arieff Tipoo, and said, "If your colleagues behave like this, we shall ask them to leave the courtroom."
The cross-examination continued without any major hitches until lunch recess and will resume on Sunday.
Coerced to propose
Ahsanul Haq tried to establish during his cross-examination that the people of the area, especially Hindus were generally supportive of Salauddin Quader and that he remains a popular man in his constituency of Rauzan.
When Ahsanul Haq said whether Prafulla's eldest brother Satya was the proposer for Salauddin's candidature in one of the national elections, he said, "Yes, but that was secured under coercion."
The defence counsel shot back, "What about his (Satya's) daughter working for their company? Was that under coercion too?"
However, when Prafulla replied, "That is not true. Can you even tell me when she worked there?" the defence counsel told the court he wanted to ask other questions before coming back to that point.
Salauddin Quader's lawyer then proceeded to suggest that Abdullah Al Harun, a rival of his client, had conspired with Prafulla to sue the BNP MP. Prafulla disagreed with the suggestion.
At a later stage of the cross-examination, the defence counsel suggested that Satya's widow, Namita was Chairperson of Kundeshwari Board of Directors only in name and Prafulla in fact ran the show and enjoyed the fruits of their business. "That is not true," said the witness.
Ahsanul Haq asked, "Does she get a salary?" to which Prafulla answered that Namita did not receive a salary but was given an allowance as the Chairperson.
The witness was then asked to name all the directors of the company, which he did. They included Prafulla, his wife, son, daughter-in-law, Namita, Satya's son and daughter-in-law.
"But the shares are different for each of them." Prafulla agreed, "Yes, they are."
"And it is only your family that wields the influence and has all the authority," suggested the defence lawyer. Prafulla replied it was not true.
Salauddin Quader in ICT
The prosecution submitted formal charges against Salauddin Quader on Nov 14, 2011 and the tribunal took them into cognisance three days later.
A former prime ministerial adviser on parliamentary affairs when BNP chief Khaleda Zia was in office, the Chittagong MP was shown arrested for war crimes charges on Dec 20, 2010, five days after his arrest.
The investigating agency submitted a 119-page report with around 8,000-page data to the chief prosecutor on Oct 3 in a bid to prove allegations of war crimes during the 1971 Liberation War.
The BNP leader was indicted on Apr 4 on 23 charges of war crimes.
Besides Jamaat-e-Islami executive council member Delwar Hossain Sayedee whose case is the most advanced and Salauddin Quader, Jamaat chief Matiur Rahman Nizami, Secretary General Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla have been detained on war crimes charges.
The tribunal also sent Jamaat-e-Islami's former chief Ghulam Azam to jail on Jan 11 and indicted him on five different charges on May 13.
The second tribunal, set up on Mar 22, 2012, has given Abdul Alim, former BNP MP and member of Ziaur Rahman's cabinet, an indefinite bail while his trial proceeds.
Jamaat-e-Islami assistant secretary general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman was indicted on June 4 on seven counts of crimes.
The second tribunal was set up to expedite the war crimes trials for atrocities during the 1971 Liberation War.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1810h