November 21, 2026

4 Sayedee petitions rejected

The first war crimes tribunal of Bangladesh on Sunday rejected four of six petitions Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee filed.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 29 Jul 2012, 03:26 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:04 PM

Dhaka, Jul 29 (bdnews24.com) — The first war crimes tribunal of Bangladesh on Sunday rejected four of six petitions Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee filed. The court did not dispose of one of the applications and said it would be "kept with the records". As regards the sixth petition where the defence sought copies of two police reports filed by Sayedee's war crimes investigator, tribunal Chairman Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq said an order would be passed on Monday. Set up to deal with crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, the three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1 indicted the Jamaat executive council member on 20 counts of war crimes including murder, rape, arson and loot on Oct 3, 2011. Abdur Razzaq, chief defence counsel of the entire Jamaat leadership currently behind bars on war crimes charges, as well as Mizanul Islam and Tanvir Ahmed Al-Amin argued for the petitions. While the court desired to hear defence arguments for one petition, defence counsel Razzaq urged that the judges hear the defence for each petition. Four of the petitions were related to the tribunal's decision to receive as evidence15 witness statements given to the investigation officer, ASP Mohammad Helal Uddin, who faced cross-examination for the 38th time on Sunday. The tribunal had decided on Mar 29, after hearing both sides at length, to partially allow a prosecution petition to have 46 witness statements, given to the investigation officer, receiving as evidence. The tribunal added a caution indicating that it would keep in mind that the witnesses were not under oath and furthermore that they were produced in court for cross-examination. This ruling came on the basis of two police reports filed by the investigation officer that substantiated the prosecution's claim that some witnesses were 'traceless' and had perhaps left for India. Some others, who were being threatened by goons loyal to Sayedee, could not be located. One of the witnesses was too ill to travel to Dhaka and had lost her senses. Regarding the other witnesses, the court rejected the application. The prosecution had cited a provision (section 19.2) of the tribunal's law which allows receiving witness statements in case of death, or unreasonable delay or expenditure for the tribunal to produce them. The defence then produced, what it claimed, records of the witness home that showed that those people had indeed come to Dhaka but were not produced before the court. The defence went on to say that there had been a fraud upon court. The prosecution denied existence of any such records at the witness home and the court later said that the defence had to prove the authenticity of the records they produced in order for them to be admissible. On Sunday the court decided to keep one of the applications, pleading the court to call 38 persons as court witnesses, related to that decision with the records. Abdur Razzaq was keen that the court hears him on the issue. But Justice Huq said it was not really needed and the tribunal did not desire to hear the defence. "All your grounds have already been stated in the petition. Besides, people will be called as court witnesses only if it feels so. Not on the basis of an application of the defence or the prosecution." Razzaq suggested that his submissions might change the court's opinion. "Your lordship can also stop me if it turns out to be irrelevant." Referring to the counsel's standing, Justice Huq said, "But it does not look nice to stop Mr Razzaq after five minutes." The tribunal chairman eventually managed to dissuade the senior counsel saying that Razzaq's insistence to hear him on this application would compel the court to adopt stiffer measures like disposing of applications in their chambers without bringing them to the court. An application seeking copies of the police reports of Mar 17 and Mar 19, which the prosecution submitted to the tribunal, will be disposed of on Monday. Justice Huq said that the tribunal would give its order the following day indicating that it would not be a short one and that the court thought it should deliberate on the matter. So far the tribunal has witnessed rounds of arguments over whether investigation reports should be furnished to the defence. The tribunal ruled in that regard that all documents that are relied upon must be furnished to the defence, and as such the investigation report did not qualify since the prosecution's case would rely upon witness statements, documents and the formal charges. Another petition sought for the mobile numbers of 18 staff members of the witness house. A fourth application sought for certain details of summons issued upon the 46 witnesses that the prosecution had said would be rather difficult to produce in court. Both applications were rejected. The fifth petition sought to have four counts against Sayedee dropped. The four charges correspond with two cases filed by Mahbubul Alam Howladar and Manik Poshari — both prosecution witnesses — in Pirojpur. The defence position was that since those cases have not been disposed of, the corresponding charges should be dropped at the tribunal. The tribunal chairman said that the court had rejected a similar petition in the war crimes case against BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury and this one would be no different. A junior member of the defence team, Tanvir Ahmed Al-Amin placed the sixth petition, moving the court disallow certain documents that the prosecution had submitted without adhering to the tribunal's provisions. His point was that these documents were supposed to be submitted before commencement of the trial. Al-Amin said in his submissions that since the prosecution had not abided by the law, these documents should be removed from the list of exhibits. The tribunal, however, did not pay much heed to the petition and rejected it saying that the defence team should not make things difficult but should rather keep things open and flexible, so that they might also enjoy the privilege if in case they came upon such a document and needed to submit it as an exhibit. bdnews24.com/ta/bd/2050h
Related Stories