Split verdict on ICT law change plea
The petition will now go to the chief justice who will assign a third judge to settle the issue, says a lawyer.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
13 May 2012, 10:27 AM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:46 PM
Dhaka, May 13 (bdnews24.com)— The High Court on Sunday returned a split verdict on a petition challenging the legitimacy of amendments to the International Crimes Tribunals Act (ICTA) of 1973.
The bench's senior judge, Justice Farid Ahammad, issued a rule on the government over the matter while the other judge, Justice Sheikh Hasan Arif, rejected the petition altogether.
In his order, Justice Ahammad ordered the law and home secretaries to reply to his rulings in four weeks, one of which asked the two to explain why insertion of 'individual and group of individuals' into the Act would not be declared unconstitutional.
The judge also asked the two secretaries to explain why inclusion of 'any individual, group of individuals or organisation' in article 47 (3) of the constitution should not be declared unlawful in accordance with the Section 15 of the 15th Amendment to the Constitution.
Advocate TH Khan argued the case for the petitioner at the hearing while Attorney General Mahbubey Alam represented the government at the hearing.
An Advocate from Chittagong, Morshedur Rahman Chowdhury, filed the public interest petition.
Advocate Khan said the split verdict meant the petition will now go to the Chief Justice who will assign a third judge to settle the issue.
"If the court verdict is favourable, our lawyers say, 'Much obliged' and if the verdict goes against them, they say, 'As your lordship pleased.' I have had a new problem. What should I say? I said, 'May Allah bless us to sense of justice'."
"I cannot recall another example of a bench giving split order over issuance of a ruling in my 60 years in this profession. Split orders galore in this term," Khan added.
The government constituted International Crimes Tribunal by amending the 1973 Act. Trial of suspected war criminals began at the International War Crimes Tribunal.
Currently, nine people including six Jamaat-e-Islami and two BNP leaders are standing trial.
bdnews24.com/sn/eh/bd/1557h