Sloppy paperwork plagues ICT-1
Deposition continued through the day amid jolts and starts and is set to go on for at least another day, Tanim Ahmed reports
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
11 Apr 2012, 08:32 AM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:39 PM
Tanim Ahmed
Dhaka, Apr 11 (bdnews24.com) — Sloppy paperwork continued to plague the proceedings of the case against Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee at the war crimes tribunal on Wednesday.
Deposition of the case investigation officer, Mohammad Helal Uddin, continued through the day amid jolts and starts and is set to continue for at least another day.
Some of the newspaper reports that Helal Uddin presented as exhibits were supplied to the defence in the morning while in some of the cases the tribunal chairman sent one of his bench clerks to make photocopies of the documents.
The defence pointed out that for some of the exhibits, the prosecution had not even supplied the defence with either the seizure list or custody details of the documents.
All these were provided to the defence while the items were being exhibited and the court came to a virtual standstill a few times awaiting photocopies for the defence from the tribunal's own offices.
Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq, chairman of the three-judge International Crimes Tribunal, set up to deal with crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, added to the court records that documents of certain exhibits were supplied to the defence while the court was in session.
Justice Huq had the court stenographer write down that exhibits 61, 92, 93, 122 and 123 were given to the defence while the court was in session. After lunch, he added three more exhibits — 158, 162 and 200 — with the same note.
Defence counsel Mizanul Islam had drawn the court's attention in this regard in the morning saying that the defence had not received the items, the seizure lists or even the custody documents of certain exhibits.
"The tribunal passed an order saying that it would be considered to have been submitted if the items are with the court. But the fact of the matter is that we do not have the items yet," he said.
This was after prosecutor Syed Haider Ali, conducting Sayedee's case, informed the tribunal in the morning that the defence had been supplied with all the documents.
But as regards some of the exhibits, it turned out that the prosecution had not provided the defence anything — the documents, seizure lists or the custody details — that would provide the defence with some idea of the documents that the prosecution intended to rely upon.
Referring to a collection of foreign press reports during 1971, which was the source of the defence's discontent on Tuesday and eventually led them to walk out of the court, the defence lawyer said, "In that case, we at least had the seizure list and custody details. But for some of the documents being exhibited today, we did not even have that."
However, when the tribunal chief, Justice Huq, proceeded to record the matter, the prosecutor objected saying that the court might as well have noted down "with reservations of the defence".
Justice Huq said, "I am merely noting down the bare facts."
Prosecutor Ali: But "with reservations" would suffice as well.
Justice Huq: But we would not be able to remember why it was that the defence had objected. These are the bare facts.
The investigation officer continued to enter mostly newspaper articles as evidence against Sayedee.
The day came to an end on another procedural issue relating to evidence. Prosecutor Haider Ali, sensing that the court would be adjourned soon as it was approaching 4pm, asked the tribunal what the procedure would be regarding books.
He said the books were available in the market and had been submitted to the tribunal. "But do we also have to supply copies of those books to the defence."
The tribunal chair shook his head indicating that he did not consider that absolutely necessary if they were widely available.
Tribunal member A K M Zaheer Ahmed said, "What you can, however, do is to mark certain pages of the books that you will be referring to."
Mizanul Islam spoke up at this point and said that list of these books had not been provided to the defence at the time of formal charge submission that the prosecution should have done.
There was no indication from the prosecution that these books would be used as evidence.
Prosecutor Haider Ali said that the list had been provided to the defence by way of the two volumes that he had given to the tribunal and the defence the day the investigation officer's deposition had begun.
Mizanul Islam agreed that the prosecutor had, but pointed out to the tribunal that these were not provided to the defence at the time of submission of formal charges.
Judge Zaheer Ahmed agreed on the point and asked the prosecutor, "Mr Islam raises a pertinent question, whether you had complied with the regulations."
The prosecutor told the tribunal that the provision cited (section 16.2) was not the only one relating to evidence. "I can always submit evidence under [section] 19.1 (of the International Crimes Tribunal Act of 1973)."
The tribunal, however, called it a day with the matter pending. Judge Zaheer Ahmed told the prosecutor, "I suppose we could hear your arguments (Thursday) morning."
The tribunal is also scheduled to hear a number of review petitions of BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury on Thursday.
FIRST CASE TO TRIAL
Sayedee's is the first case to proceed to the trial stage at the tribunal. The prosecution on Sept 4 proposed framing of charges against him on 31 counts for crimes against humanity and genocide.
On Oct 3, the tribunal indicted Sayedee on 20 counts.
The tribunal also sent Jamaat's former chief Ghulam Azam to jail on Jan 11. His indictment hearing began on Feb 15 and the tribunal is scheduled to give an order on Apr 17.
Besides Sayedee, Jamaat chief Matiur Rahman Nizami, secretary general Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla, and Bangladesh Nationalist Party's standing committee member and MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury have been detained on war crimes charges.
The tribunal granted conditional bail to former BNP lawmaker and minister Abdul Alim on March 31 last year. The bail was extended further on Jan 16, ordering him to be present in the court on Apr 25 when the prosecution is expected to place formal charges against him.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1810h