Published : 27 Jul 2013, 11:59 AM
Updated : 20 Oct 2022, 03:37 PM
Also Read:
Protest erupts over BCS resultsAlso Read:
34th BCS results up for reviewAlso Read:
Violence, vandalism at DU over quota protestThe quota system sparked a debate in the country after the recent announcement of the results of 34th Bangladesh Civil Service (BCS) preliminary examinations. A group of students, who had failed to clear the test, hit the street demanding cancellation of all quotas including the one meant for children of freedom fighters. Amidst widespread demonstrations against the quota system, another group emerged demanding continuation of the system.
Former PSC Chairman Saadat Hussain spoke to bdnews24.com on the issue. The retired Secretary says the quota system should be amended along with the examination system.
Faijul Siddikii conducted the interview. Photojournalist Asaduzzaman Pramanik accompanied him.
bdnews24.com: How would you evaluate the quota system?
Saadat Hussain: This system has no Constitutional basis, but still it is a national issue. Complexities surrounding the issue have made it more difficult to resolve it.
The quota system (cadre and non-cadre) is applicable everywhere from first grade to fourth grade jobs. There are different types of quotas. Akbar Ali Khan has researched and found there are 257 types of quotas in Bangladesh.
And so, finding a solution to one or two types won’t do. If anyone wants to work on quotas, he or she will have to work on all forms of quotas. In a 2009 report, we said the quota system had reached a stage wherein complexities associated with it can’t be solved with mere human qualities.
bdnews24.com: There is a provision to reserve 56 percent government jobs for quotas. But many posts for quotas are vacant in 27th to 30th BCS. Why do you think it has happened?
Saadat Hussain: Quotas not only mean BCS quotas. Everyone’s talking about freedom fighter quotas. But there are quotas for women, districts, indigenous people etc. Each quota has again divisions.
bdnews24.com: There are many districts which are deprived of quotas. What is your opinion on this?
Saadat Hussain: The district quota system is based on population and because of this, small districts are deprived. As a result, purposes of creating such quotas have backfired. Districts like Meherpur, Lalmonirhat, Serpur, Laxmipur have no district quotas.
What we did is, if there are 189 posts, one seat each should be given to the districts.
And if there are over 18 posts, then there would be one post for each division. We had declared 31 districts backward and allocated two percent quotas for them.
bdnews24.com: In that case, how do you think the quotas should be allotted?
Saadat Hussain: I believe a different quota system should be introduced for the BCS where merit will be given topmost priority.
Apart from the gazetted officers, there are thousands of posts in first and second class non-cadre jobs. A different quota system should be introduced there.
Those having third and fourth class jobs will not be the country’s policymakers. So, there should be a different quota system for them.
Increase quota allocation where the posts don’t require merits and decrease quotas in cadre posts.
bdnews24.com: The PSC published a reviewed result of the BCS preliminary tests after demonstrations demanding cancellation of the quota system recently. What is your opinion on the matter?
Saadat Hussain: Solutions provided by either the ruling or the opposition party won’t do. A solution should be worked out entailing all the stakeholders in the country.
A temporary solution should be churned out for several years so that everyone can sustain it.
bdnews24.com: A lot of countries have a quota system, how is it implemented in those countries?
Saadat Hussain: Look, there are quotas in many countries, including the US. But they’re applied differently. In the US, those eligible for quotas are given a number at the beginning, and then everyone has to compete in open exams.
bdnews24.com: You formed a committee on quotas when you were Chairman of PSC. Do you know anything about its current status?
Saadat Hussain: We did some basic research on quotas, but I won’t go into details. Former advisor to the caretaker government, Akbar Ali Khan and the current Chief Election Commissioner, Kazi Rakibuddin Ahmed carried out a study in March, 2008 on the existing quota system in the Bangladesh Civil Service.
The 61-page long report is at the PSC. It’s a world class research. They found that quotas are important in Bangladesh’s context, but there may be questions about its quantity or application.
Quotas are preserved firstly for the freedom fighters, then for women and the indigenous communities. At present whoever is privileged with more than one quota is given first preference. For example, if a tribal woman is the daughter of a freedom fighter, she will be considered first. As a result, it could lead to a situation that despite doing well, there would be no prospect of availing the district or women quotas for someone in Rangamati. I think there are scopes for irregularities and corruption in this case.
bdnews24.com: Are you saying the quota system needs a major overhaul?
Saadat Hussain: Of course. Those who have reaped its benefit once, they and their descendents should not be eligible for it again.
Let’s say, I enjoyed quota for the backward region. I have used this advantage to develop social and financial standing, to help establish my family and children. Therefore, they should not be beneficiaries of the quota system.
Similarly, the quotas for freedom fighters, the indigenous community and women must be regulated, so that a person after getting benefits of the quota once cannot avail it a second time.
Only then everyone will benefit from the quotas.