Published :
10 Sep 2011, 02:15 PM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:25 PM
Dhaka, Sept 10 (bdnews24.com)—Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) president Khandker Mahbub Hossain has said judges taking money from the prime minister's relief fund is 'rare'.
Giving his take on the recent debate on the BNP chief's remarks that former chief justice A B M Khairul Haque had cancelled the caretaker government provision for money, Mahbub on Saturday said, "The remarks by the opposition leader were political, she herself will clarify it."
He also said the judiciary had better decide whether those remarks amounted to contempt of court, as alleged by the law minister earlier in the day.
"Many of the judges took financial aid from the prime minister's welfare fund for treatment as it is the state's responsibility (to look after them). But it is a rare incident to take money from the relief fund."
"So far as I know, he (Khairul Haque) and his wife are financially solvent. But he took money from the prime minister's relief fund while he was giving the verdict on a petition on the constitution. The people are greatly confused about it," he alleged.
Mahbub also claimed that Khairul Haque was a 'controversial judge'.
Law minister Shafique Ahmed said what Khaleda had said was "not only contemptuous but also (would) malign the image of the judiciary".
Justice Khairul Haque headed the seven-strong Appellate Bench that ruled that the non-party provision ran contrary to the principles of democracy. But the bench recommended holding of the two following elections under the caretakers.
Khairul Haque would have headed the 90-day interim, unelected caretaker cabinet if the Awami League government had gone ahead with the apex court recommendations.
The BNP chief on Aug 31 also blamed the judge for 'destroying the judiciary and making it partisan'.
The parliamentary standing committee on law ministry on Sep 6 said the remarks were way beyond courtesy, mean and derogatory; and said Khaleda should apologise to the nation.
The committee also urged her to withdraw the statement and called on authorities "to take legal measures" unless she did so.
A list was also placed in the meeting having names of 31 judges, 27 of whom had taken money from the prime minister's welfare fund and four others from the relief fund.
The next day, attorney general Mahbubey Alam advised that Khaleda offer an apology. He alleged that she had made the comments to make the historic verdicts that the former chief justice had presided over 'questionable'.
At a press call at the South Hall of the Supreme Court, the SCBA chief said Khairul Haque did not clarify the matter when journalists had asked him following news reports on the issue. "He rather said, 'Leave me alone'."
The SCBA chief also blamed judges for not publishing the full verdict on the 13th amendment to the constitution. "Khairul Haque is also responsible for this. He also spoke to media as a chief justice violating the code of conduct."
The caretaker provision introduced in 1996 through the 13th amendment to the constitution was abolished on Mar 10 by the Appellate Division bench. On June 30, it was removed from the constitution by the 15th amendment.
Khaleda had to leave her cantonment house upon orders by the highest court of the country that also threw out the fifth and seventh amendments to the constitution. All these verdicts were presided over by Justice Khairul Haque.
The verdict on the Fifth Amendment, which gave legal cover to all orders and martial law proclamations by Bangladesh's first military ruler Gen Ziaur Rahman, particularly enraged the BNP.
bdnews24.com/sn/pd/gna/pks/bd/2136h