November 21, 2026

ICT declines to budge on Tajul

The Jamaat-e-Islami defence counsel will remain barred from appearing in the war crimes tribunal at least until Dec 23. Updates

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 22 Nov 2012, 07:41 AM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:32 PM

Dhaka, Nov 22 (bdnews24.com) — Jamaat-e-Islami defence counsel Tajul Islam remains barred from appearing in the first war crimes tribunal of Bangladesh until at least Dec 23. Senior lawyers and bar leaders apologised unconditionally before the International Crimes Tribunal – 1, set up to try crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, had directed three counsels to show cause why action should not be taken against them for unprofessional conduct. The court said it would rule on the matter on Dec 23, although chief Jamaat counsel Abdur Razzaq appealed twice to allow Tajul Islam to appear. The tribunal said it was unwilling to 'touch the order except for shifting the date'. "It will be clear to everyone after the judgement," tribunal Chairman Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq said. Opposition-leaning lawyers stood before the tribunal one after another and repeated their plea of unconditional apology on behalf of Tajul Islam, Mizanul Islam and Tanvir Ahmed Al-Amin. While Tajul Islam has been appearing at the tribunal since the first day representing the Jamaat leadership, senior counsel Mizanul Islam has been leading the trial of Jamaat leaders at the first tribunal. Tanvir Ahmed is in the team of lawyers assisting the senior lawyers of Jamaat. All three had been found to have exhibited unruly behaviour in the court. The notice said that they were shouting inside the court and used language unbecoming of them. Furthermore, the court had referred to an allegation of Tajul Islam, in its notice, that the tribunal might have been involved with the abduction of a witness, which had sparked the entire commotion in the first place on Nov 5. Tajul Islam on Oct 22 had been ordered to show cause for an unprofessional conduct when he walked out of the courtroom showing his back to the judges blatantly disregarding the tribunal's caution. Former BNP law minister Moudud Ahmed, currently a deputy leader of the opposition, appeared first and admitted that the young lawyer, meaning Tajul Islam, had committed a mistake. "There is no doubt that they are at fault." The BNP leader went on to offer an unreserved apology and declined from justifying their actions in any way. The tribunal Chairman pointed out to the former Vice President that he had even read out the rules to Tajul Islam despite which he turned and left, "Showing his back to us." "That was very wrong of him," agreed Moudud and continued, "We appeal to the grace and mercy of this court. He is a dedicated lawyer and very active for his clients." "No doubt, and that is why we are rather sorry," it was the tribunal chief's turn to agree as well. "But his activities must be such that is becoming of a lawyer. He must keep that in mind." Justice Huq noted that Tajul Islam was fighting for his comrades, that he was fighting for his friends. "And that is all very good but his behaviour is becoming worse and worse." "He has done wrong and now if you don't forgive him then you would also be depriving his clients of a good lawyer and it will be very difficult for them to find a substitute," pleaded Moudud. Abdur Razzaq then stood before the judges and said that he offered no justification of the actions of the counsels. "But he places himself at the mercy of the court." Razzaq explained that the lawyer did not have any intention to malign the court or its dignity and had only mentioned the word 'tribunal' inadvertently in the heat of the moment when he wanted to mean that the investigation agency might have been involved with the abduction. Razzaq said that his younger colleague on the defence team had offered his 'unreserved apology' without offering any 'justification' for what he had done. The chief defence counsel also mentioned that Tajul understood he should have been more circumspect about his activities and words. "He subjects himself to the mercy of the tribunal." The senior lawyer prayed that his plea be granted. He was followed by Zainul Abedin, the Supreme Court Bar Association President, who said that he had come before the tribunal as the President of the bar to apologise on behalf of the 'young lad, who has a bright career in front of him'. "If the courts lose their standing and respect, so do the lawyers and vice versa." The senior lawyer said that although the allegations were grave, it was up to the court to find mercy for Tajul. "Not everyone's sense of language and expression are the same. Not everyone has command of judicious language. And your show-cause is enough to caution him." Abedin continued to say, "But if you are not gracious, this lad might have a hard time before him." He vouched for his younger bar member saying that Tajul would from now exercise more restraint and be ever respectful to the court. "Forgiveness is a great virtue and it is you who can show it." Rafiqul Islam Miah also spoke for the defendants and said, "There is no question of explanation." He said Tajul offered unconditional apology subjecting himself to the mercy of the court. Prosecutors Zead-Al-Malum and Haider Ali also stood before the stand. Malum made the point that whatever decision the tribunal took, it had to be an independent one considering the whole situation. "You will remember that not the people of this country but there are eyes and ears abroad following your actions intently." Haider Ali referred to the matter of witness abduction and pointed out that the day the witness was abducted had been fixed for argument not witness testimony — which he appeared to suggest, raised questions about the defence complaint of the abducted witness. "I would urge you to consider the entire context before you reach your decision and whether such a turn of events was at all acceptable." Justice Huq said the tribunal was looking to give a good judgement and asked Abdur Razzaq to provide the court with similar cases at home or abroad. "We want to be satisfied with the order, so we need to see how other courts have dealt with similar things." Razzaq readily agreed to assist the court to the best of his abilities. He then pleaded that till the order, on Dec 23, the bar on Tajul Islam be lifted. Justice Huq, however, did not agree and when the senior counsel appealed a second time, he said the tribunal was not willing to touch the order till the date of order. He said, "We will take more time and hear you again if needed. But we want to give a good judgement." bdnews24.com/ta/nir/1847h
Related Stories