Published :
02 Jun 2013, 05:44 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 10:44 AM
It also failed to take statements of Shah and two other accused standing trials in Canada in another case lodged by the police of that country over the same charges.
ACC chief lawyer Anisul Haque, who was on the two-member team that also included plaintiff of the case Mirza Zahidul Alam, informed journalists of their failure at the commission office on Sunday afternoon.
But ACC Chairman Ghulam Rahman claimed that the team came back with ‘satisfactory progresses’.
Shah, former Vice-President of Canadian consultancy firm, reportedly mentioned in his diary the deal on percentage sharing of the bribe to be given to senior officials of Bangladesh government for consultancy work of Padma project.
The team went to Canada on May 19 to collect Shah’s diary, record statements of Mohammad Ismail, SNC-Lavalin’s former Director, Kevin Wallace, former President of Candu Energy, a subsidiary of SNC-Lavalin, and Shah, and observe the trial process of Canadian court.
Three days later on May 22, ACC Secretary M Faizur Rahman Chowdhury had told reporters during the commission’s monthly briefing that the team was trying to collect Shah’s diary. He said: “If (collection of the diary is) not possible, its pages or copy will be collected.”
Alam came back home on Tuesday and Haque on Thursday.
The ACC chief lawyer told journalists: “Now the diary is the property of Canada court. We applied to get (it). But the Canadian court said that they could not hand over the diary or its copy to us until the trial ended.”
Asked about the recording of statements of Shah and Ismail, he said: “We tried to talk to them through their lawyers. But Ramesh Shah’s lawyer didn’t respond to our email and Islamil’s attorney told us that his client was not interested to talk to us.”
After a prolonged row with the World Bank over the allegation of the bribery conspiracy in the $2.9 billion project, the Bangladesh government told the global lender that it did not need the $1.2 billion fund that the global lending agency had pledged for the country’s largest-ever infrastructure project.
Later, the Asian Development Bank and JICA, two other co-financers, pull out of the project.
The World Bank banned SNC-Lavalin for 10 years in all projects financed by the lender over the bribery conspiracy. It also blacklisted over hundred associate firms of SNC-Lavalin for one year.
Anisul Haque told reporters on Sunday that in Canada decisions on whether a case would proceed to trial phase were made though ‘committal proceedings’.
“First there are arguments in the court and decisions are made on the basis of that. We talked to the authorities (Royal Canadian Mounted Police). They told us that committal proceedings have ended. Trials will begin formally on July 10.”
He said ACC team might need to go to Canada again to observe the trials.
Later, the commission Chairman told reporters: “Satisfactory progresses have been attained towards the objectives for what they (ACC team) were sent. They’ve brought some information.”
The ACC on Dec 17 filed the case at Banani Police Station against seven over the bribery conspiracy.
The other accused are former Secretary to the Bridges Division Mosharraf Hossain Bhuiyan, Superintendent Engineer of Bangladesh Bridge Authority Kazi Mohammad Ferdous, Executive Engineer of Roads and Highways Department Reaz Ahmed Zaber and Deputy Managing Director of Engineering and Planning Consultant, SNC Lavalin’s local agent, Mohammad Mostafa.
Media had reported that Shah mentioned in his diary that former Communications Minister Syed Abul Hossain was to get 4 percent of Tk 380 million in bribe from the supervision work money.
Names of Prime Minister’s Economic Affairs Advisor Moshiur Rahman, former State Minister for Foreign Affairs Abul Hassan Chowdhury and Mosharraf of Bridges Division were there in the diary, which was seized by the Canadian police.