November 21, 2026

US unsure when, if can hand over prisons to Iraq

US forces are taking longer than expected to train Iraqis to run their prisons and have no clear view of when, if ever, they can entrust security suspects they hold to the overall control of the Iraqi authorities.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 02 Feb 2007, 11:49 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:20 PM

BAGHDAD, Feb 2 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - US forces are taking longer than expected to train Iraqis to run their prisons and have no clear view of when, if ever, they can entrust security suspects they hold to the overall control of the Iraqi authorities. Acknowledging reports of torture and abuse in Iraqi-run prisons, the commander of US camps that house 15,500 detainees said he was working to raise standards among Iraqis to the point where Washington can hand over its responsibilities without breaching its obligations to protect its prisoners from harm. "The biggest challenge is legal authority to hold detainees," Major General Jack Gardner told Reuters in an interview, saying Iraq first needed appropriate facilities and to show it could meet international "standards of care". "That's the goal. If we meet those criteria, then we will transfer. If we don't, we won't. It's not time dependent." Washington is training Iraqis to run its military prisons at Camp Bucca in the south and at Camp Cropper near Baghdad, which replaced the ill-famed Abu Ghraib jail last year. It is also offering training to guards in Iraq's own prisons, while local US units are expected to check on Iraqi jails in their areas. Gardner said recruitment and training for the US camps had not gone as quickly as hoped. He said in April he hoped to have 3,600 trained at three jails by the end of 2006. In fact, there are only about 1,050, working with about 5,000 Americans -- a similar number of US troops as a year ago. The shortfall is partly due to handing over a third jail, with 550 trained guards, to Iraqi control. Training has taken longer than hoped and some recruits were dismissed on security grounds or for breaching guidelines on care and custody. The hope now is to complete recruitment and training this year. Asked what would happen if Washington judged that conditions for a handover of its prisoners had not been met by the time it withdraws the bulk of its forces -- something some see starting next year -- Gardner declined to speculate. Pressed on whether it might simply have to release the suspects it holds, he said: "The end-state is we ... do what's right, to balance the security requirements but also make sure that the people in detention are treated fairly. "Our criteria for transfer in our facilities for detainees are fairly stringent and will be adhered to. How this evolves over the next 18 months is unknown. "Our goal is to work through that over the next 6-8 months to come up solutions that meets the criteria we have set." He said progress in resolving Iraq's sectarian conflict could ease the problem of abuse in Iraqi jails. Many minority Sunni Arabs, whose once-dominant community still accounts for 90 percent of detainees in the US system, resent a process whose critics point to the fact only a small proportion of those held are ever prosecuted and convicted. But many also fear arrest by Iraqi police and troops, many of whose units are viewed by Sunnis as working in league with hostile Shia sectarian militias. The US military, conscious of the damage done to its own stated goals of defending human rights by the Abu Ghraib abuse scandal of 2004, has freed prisoners from Iraqi jails where it said there was evidence of torture. Iraq's government has said it is working to stamp out torture in its prisons, which some rights lobbyists say recalls the days of Saddam Hussein. Gardner said Washington was focusing on training Iraqi prison staff but acknowledged that, as US troops hand over security control of larger areas of Iraq, their ability to monitor standards in custody was limited. Overall, he said, the outlook for prisoners of the United States in Iraq was very unclear: "What the future holds, I would not begin to guess over the next year, two years." bdnews24.com/srs/1652 hrs
Related Stories