November 21, 2026

US-led group tracks N Korea WMD in murky waters

Black-clad agents rappel from a helicopter to board a suspicious ship on the high seas and after missile parts are found, naval vessels escort the ship to port, where the illicit cargo is confiscated.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 26 Oct 2006, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 06:45 PM

TOKYO, October 27 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) – Black-clad agents rappel from a helicopter to board a suspicious ship on the high seas and after missile parts are found, naval vessels escort the ship to port, where the illicit cargo is confiscated. That's the Hollywood scene conjured up by the Proliferation Security Initiative (PSI), a US--led effort to halt trade in weapons of mass destruction that has been given fresh momentum after North Korea conducted a nuclear test earlier this month. The reality, though, may be less dramatic -- more portside neighbourhood watch than high-seas sheriff -- according to analysts, who say Chinese and South Korean misgivings and legal doubts could well deter swoops in international waters. 'The cooperation of the Chinese and South Koreans is absolutely essential,' said James Cotton of the Australian Defence Force Academy, who has studied PSI and North Korea. 'PSI now has the essential legal basis that was lacking before, but how that authority will now be used is not as clear-cut.' The three-year-old PSI groups countries that agree to share intelligence information and work against proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. Now boasting over 60 members, the arrangement has from the outset had North Korea as one obvious, if unstated, target. A UN resolution imposing sanctions on North Korea after its October 9 nuclear test appears to give PSI a firmer legal basis than before to target North Korean shipments. But Washington may be unwilling to test the still fuzzy limits of that authority. 'If their intelligence satellites detect missiles or components directly related to weapons of mass destruction being shipped from North Korea, I think there is a chance the United States would, indeed, interdict,' said Mark Valencia, a Hawaii-based maritime policy expert, referring to the practice of halting ships, planes or other vehicles for inspections. 'But the idea of a kind of screen at sea or in the air in the region is not likely,' he said. US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, on a tour of Japan, South Korea, China and Russia that ended Sunday, appeared to back away from interdictions on the high seas and focus instead on less controversial screenings in ports, Valencia added. Since the UN resolution against North Korea, Japan has indicated a willingness to support cargo inspections to the extent allowed by its pacifist constitution. Australia, another close US ally, has offered to send a warship. But China has declined to join PSI, wary of involvement in a loose US--led coalition outside traditional security moorings. South Korea -- on the front line in any confrontation with the North -- also remains cautious. 'China probably won't oppose the PSI, but nor will it want to give its backing,' said Xu Guangyu, a researcher at the China Arms Control and Disarmament Association, a government-sponsored think tank in Beijing. 'We don't want to see actions that could escalate tensions or spark confrontation. It wouldn't serve China's interests to become closely involved.' Experts said interdictions could escalate the crisis. 'North Korea doesn't have the various means to allow them to respond carefully in a calibrated way,' said Mark Shulman of Pace Law School in New York. 'There is a chance that things get out of hand.' Legal uncertainties also linger. Before this month's UN resolution, maritime law experts had mostly agreed that PSI members lacked the authority to halt and inspect a vessel suspected of carrying WMD on the high seas without permission from its captain or the country whose flag the ship is flying. Whether that changed Security Council Resolution 1718 is still being debated by lawyers and diplomats. The resolution calls on UN members to take steps, including 'as necessary' the inspection of cargoes to and from North Korea, to prevent illicit trafficking in nuclear, chemical or biological weapons. At the insistence of China and Russia, two of the five permanent council members with veto power, the resolution was based on Article 41 of the UN Charter's Chapter VII, which rules out the use of armed force to implement sanctions. Maritime policy expert Valencia said cargo inspections in ports were more likely than interdictions on the high seas. 'What they are pushing is to check cargo passing through ports,' he said. 'That seems reasonable and logical and in conformance with (UN Security Council Resolution) 1718.' Some experts, however, think the resolution leaves enough wiggle room to allow interdictions. 'For now, it is carefully crafted to leave ambiguity,' Pace Law School's Shulman said. 'I think if a WMD or a component to make it is shipped to or from North Korea, it will be interdicted.' bdnews24.com/srs/aak/1230 hrs
Related Stories