November 21, 2026

Scottish defeat leaves problem for Blair successor

Scottish nationalists committed to independence from Britain became the biggest party in the Scottish parliament on Friday in elections which left a political headache for Prime Minister Tony Blair's successor.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 05 May 2007, 05:08 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 03:03 PM

EDINBURGH HELLOMOTO, engage the brain first and then open mouth Martyn Warwick LONDON, May 5 (bdnews24.com)-In the heat of debate, in arguments, after a few beers, people can tend to say some pretty daft things. Usually though, by the next morning, everyone has forgotten about it and life resumes the even tenor of its way. But then there are those few who studiedly and with aforethought make or write something so stupid that it haunts them forever thereafter. And Ed Zander, the CEO of Motorola, is one captain of industry who has opened his mouth and put not just one foot but both tasselled executive loafers right in it. And it wasn't in a giveaway, off-the-cuff remark but a considered opinion given in an article run last week in the influential Wall Street Journal. In it Mr. Zander revealed, and I quote, "I love my job. I hate my customers." He might have thought at the time it was an amusing thing to say, he might not have been thinking straight, he may have let down his guard, he may even have been telling the truth, but the point is that Motorola, like every other manufacturer of telecoms equipment on the face of the planet constantly claims that "the customer is king" and at the absolute epicentre of everything they do. They bleat on and on that the customer is the reason why the company exists in the first place and while it is true that many organisations secretly hold their customers in contempt (and believe me there are plenty of them in the global telecoms industry) in public they play the game and pay serial lip service to the mantra of customer-centricity. However, with his foolish utterance, Ed Zander basically made a rod for his own back and his would be nemesis, Carl Icahn, the billionaire US investor who has his eye on Motorola and is seeking a place on the company's board, duly stepped forward to beat him soundly with it. Mr. Icahn took out a full-page advert in the self-same paper to let fly at Motorola in general and to lambaste Mr. Zander in particular. He wrote, "Motorola has suffered a critical failure in oversight and leadership" and that the company has "stumbled badly" since Mr. Zander took over as CEO. Warming to his theme, Mr. Icahn added that Zander's admission that he hates customers "sounds like something straight out of Alice in Wonderland." Mr. Zander's mistake – for that is most certainly what it is – is manna from heaven to Mr. Icahn who has taken full advantage of the continuing slide in the value of Motorola's shares to buy vast amounts of stock at knock-down prices. He has spent US$1.2 billion to date and now owns more than three per cent of Motorola's stock. He is continuing to buy more and has increasing numbers of institutional investors on his side in his quest to be elected to the board of directors. Motorola's AGM will be held next Monday, May 7, and Motorola's senior management is running scared. The top brass are well aware that investors are restless and are demanding change, especially after the company fell badly into the red in the first quarter of the current trading year Mr. Icahn has a long history of getting into underperforming companies and ripping the guts out of them, firing managers, bringing in new structures, cutting costs, boosting sales and increasing stock value. Investors like what they see but the Motorola board is terrified that the gravy train may be about to be derailed. Thus they are doing everything they can to prevent Carl Icahn being voted onto the board but the decision doesn't rest with them and by next week things might be very different. In the meantime, Motorola takes every opportunity it can to rubbish Icahn's claims and plans, saying that the company does not need what he calls "a fresh perspective" and points out that new blood has already been infused via the appointment of five new independent directors over the past three years. Motorola also claims, and it's a claim that seems remarkably divorced from reality, that Mr. Icahn does not have the expertise, business knowledge or available time to serve on the board and has also offered to "work with" him to find a compromise board candidate who would be acceptable to both parties. Carl Icahn is having none of it and is waiting on the vote due next Monday. In his Wall Street Journal advert Mr. Icahn says it is about time and "absolutely necessary" that a major independent shareholder is represented on the board. Many investors agree, but whether the number of them is sufficiently great to ensure that Carl Icahn is elected we'll just have to wait and see. Carl Icahn isn't letting up on his attack though. he writes, "Motorola has stumbled and stumbled badly. Over the past six months on this board's watch, almost $20 billion of market value, of stockholder value, of your money, has disappeared." Meanwhile Motorola shares are trading at close to a two-year low and have lost 34 per cent of their value since October 2006. Add to that the fact that profits dropped by an astonishing 48 per cent in Q4, and you can see why shareholders are angry – and that Mr. Icahn has a point. One thing is for sure. Ed Zander must be regretting the day he opened his mouth without first engaging his brain. What Motorola's disillusioned customers make of his remarks will take time to assess, but nobody likes being taken for a mug, and that' what Mr. Zander obviously believes they are. Is this a case of a corporate death wish? bdnews24.com/ask/km/1120hrs (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Scottish nationalists committed to independence from Britain became the biggest party in the Scottish parliament on Friday in elections which left a political headache for Prime Minister Tony Blair's successor. The Scottish National Party (SNP) ended 50 years of Labor dominance in Scotland in Thursday's vote and Labor suffered heavy losses in local council elections in England and lesser losses in elections to the devolved Welsh assembly. With Blair expected to announce next week he is stepping down as prime minister after a decade in power, he leaves a poisoned chalice to finance minister Gordon Brown, the 56-year-old Scot who is almost certain to succeed him. Brown must wrestle with the problem of how to revive support for the Labor Party, whose popularity has slumped because of opposition to the Iraq war, a series of political scandals and a general sense of voter fatigue with the party. Added to that he could now face the tricky problem of managing relations with a Scottish executive dominated by the SNP which has pledged to hold a referendum in three years on independence from Britain. "This is a historic moment," SNP leader Alex Salmond said. "The Labor Party has no moral authority left to govern Scotland". Brown received one piece of good news on Friday when one of his last potential rivals to succeed Blair as Labor Party leader and prime minister announced he would not stand. "I am not going to run in the leadership election," former interior minister Charles Clarke told the Times newspaper. He said he had considered a challenge but believed there was no appetite in the party for a divisive contest. His decision leaves Brown only likely to face a challenge for the leadership from one of two left-wing Labor lawmakers. In English local council elections, the opposition Conservatives, resurgent under new leader David Cameron, won around 875 council seats, inflicting heavy losses on Labor. Blair said the results were far from a rout and gave Labor a "perfectly good springboard" for the next general election, expected in 2009. The Conservatives took 40 percent of the national vote, reinforcing their credibility as a party that could challenge for power at the next general election. Labor, a staunch supporter of Scotland's 300-year-old union with England, has attacked the SNP's referendum plan. Brown said the vast majority of Scots had voted for a Scotland "that maintains its rightful place in Britain". Polls show a majority of Scots against independence and some voters backed the SNP as a protest against Labor. Final results showed the SNP with 47 seats to Labor's 46 in the 129-member Scottish parliament, which has power over issues such as health and education. The SNP's astounding gain of 20 seats compared with the 2003 election left it short of an absolute majority. Tense coalition negotiations will now take place and while the SNP are in pole position to form the new Scottish executive, there is no guarantee they will be able to do so. Labor may try to form a coalition with parties that back union with England. The Scottish vote was marred by hitches. Voters complained that tens of thousands of votes had been rejected because people were confused by complex ballot papers. Counting in some major constituencies was delayed by computer scanning glitches. (Additional reporting by Peter Griffiths, Sophie Walker and Peter Graff in London) bdnews24.com/amt/aj/1107 hrs.
Related Stories