Published : 25 Oct 2018, 11:55 AM
Updated : 19 Oct 2022, 02:21 PM
The comments by the crown prince, Mohammed bin Salman, were made during a panel discussion at an opulent investor conference in Riyadh, the Saudi capital. They came as the relationship between Saudi Arabia and Turkey continued to sour over the Oct 2 killing at the Saudi Consulate in Istanbul and as Saudi Arabia’s economic and political ties with the West are increasingly at risk.
Prince Mohammed insisted that Turkey and Saudi Arabia were collaborating to bring those who committed the killing to justice.
“The crime was really painful to all Saudis, and I believe it is painful to every human in the world,” he said in Arabic, according to a simultaneous translation. “It is a heinous crime that cannot be justified.”
Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia speaks on the second day of the Future Investment Initiative conference in Riyadh, Wednesday, Oct 24, 2018. The New York Times
The prince’s comments came amid reports by both Saudi and Turkish news agencies that he had spoken by telephone about the Khashoggi case with Saudi Arabia’s principal accuser, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey. It was the first official word that the two leaders, considered regional rivals, had spoken about the case.
Earlier in the day, Erdogan repeated his demand that those responsible for Khashoggi’s death be brought to justice. “We are determined not to allow a cover-up of this murder,” he said in a speech to Turkey’s State Council.
Some of the crown prince’s close subordinates have been implicated by Turkish officials in the killing of Khashoggi, 59, a Washington Post columnist.
Western intelligence officials have said the Saudi agents would almost certainly not have acted without the knowledge of or instructions from the 33-year-old crown prince, who is considered the de facto ruler of Saudi Arabia.
Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia speaks on the second day of the Future Investment Initiative conference in Riyadh, Wednesday, Oct 24, 2018. The New York Times
Turkish officials have said they have evidence, including audio recordings, that a team of Saudi assassins killed Khashoggi within minutes of his entry to the consulate, dismembered his body and then tried to cover up his death — even creating a fictitious trail by having a Saudi agent who resembled Khashoggi walk out of the consulate wearing the victim’s clothes.
President Donald Trump, a close ally of the Saudi royal family, has said he is sceptical of the Saudi explanations for what happened and has called the cover-up “one of the worst.”
In an interview with The Wall Street Journal on Tuesday, Trump said that ties between the United States and Saudi Arabia would be damaged if the crown prince had been dishonest with him. “Certainly it would be a very bad thing in terms of relationship,” the president said. “It would take a while to rebuild.”
Trump’s Central Intelligence Agency director, Gina Haspel, has been in Turkey for the past few days to get more information from her Turkish counterparts.
The Sabah, a pro-government Turkish newspaper, reported that Turkish officials had shared evidence including audio recordings with Haspel. US intelligence officials would not comment on Haspel’s meeting.
For the recordings to have real usefulness to the CIA or other agencies, the Turks would have to provide a full copy so US intelligence operatives can perform technical analysis and establish their authenticity. But even then, the recordings would most likely be of little value on the key policy question: whether the Saudi crown prince was connected to the killing, officials briefed on the intelligence said.
The officials said there was little reason to doubt the basic Turkish account of Khashoggi being brutally killed in the consulate. But the officials said intelligence agencies remain unconvinced that any of the information gathered from the consulate will resolve the fundamental question of the crown prince’s involvement.
Some government officials believe Prince Mohammed ordered action to be taken against Khashoggi but did not intend for him to be killed. Others believe Prince Mohammed wanted him killed.
Saudi Arabia has denied that its leaders ordered the operation against Khashoggi or even knew that it had taken place until days later.
Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia speaks on the second day of the Future Investment Initiative conference in Riyadh, Wednesday, Oct 24, 2018. The New York Times
Hariri did not address the incident, instead focusing his remarks on the development of Lebanon’s economy. But Prince Mohammed sought to joke about it.
“His Excellency Prime Minister Saad is staying for two days in Saudi Arabia,” the crown prince said, “so I hope that rumours don’t start that he’s been kidnapped.”
Mostly, the crown prince used the appearance to promote what he described as his country’s rich and glorious future.
“I don’t think that there is any challenge before the great Saudi people,” he said. “All of our projects are proceeding, reform is proceeding, our war on extremism is proceeding, our war on terrorism is proceeding, developing the kingdom of Saudi Arabia is proceeding. No matter how they try to stop our efforts, we won’t stop.”
Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia speaks on the second day of the Future Investment Initiative conference in Riyadh, Wednesday, Oct 24, 2018. The New York Times
Prince Mohammed was greeted with an ovation as he entered the ballroom at the Ritz Carlton hotel, where business leaders from around the world have converged to network and make deals — though many cancelled last week, citing the stigma of the Khashoggi scandal
Throughout the day, bankers and business executives at the conference, known as the Future Investment Initiative, wondered whether the prince would actually make an appearance, which was added and then mysteriously disappeared from the conference’s online agenda.
Despite the Khashoggi uproar, the conference hummed along on its second day, with discussions focused on capital markets, sovereign wealth funds and investing in Saudi Arabia’s emerging technology sectors.
Although pitches were being made in the hotel’s hallways, it was premature to say whether the absence of top American bankers would be a drag on deal-making or open new opportunities for investors from Russia and China.
On Tuesday, Saudi Aramco announced the signing of 15 deals worth more than $30 billion with companies in eight countries: the United States, France, China, Japan, the United Arab Emirates, Britain, South Korea and India.
Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia speaks on the second day of the Future Investment Initiative conference in Riyadh, Wednesday, Oct 24, 2018. The New York Times
“It was something he had to do in some form,” said Ralph Simon, the chief executive of Mobilium Global, a London-based mobile technology company. “There was a lot of opposition to people coming to this event, and I was hoping there would be some form of public statement.”
But the shifting Saudi statements on Khashoggi have in some ways only deepened foreign suspicions about the crown prince’s role. They were fanned further by a social-media backlash Wednesday over published photographs of a staged condolence gesture by the crown prince, shown shaking hands with Salah Khashoggi, a son of the slain journalist, who is barred from leaving the kingdom.
Foreign critics of Saudi Arabia also widened on Wednesday to include the top leadership of its regional nemesis Iran, which had been conspicuously silent on the Khashoggi killing.
President Hassan Rouhani of Iran said in remarks quoted by its official news agency that “nobody could expect to see such an organised murder in the current century, and an establishment plan for such a brutal killing.”
Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia speaks on the second day of the Future Investment Initiative conference in Riyadh, Wednesday, Oct 24, 2018. The New York Times
Saudi officials at the investment conference tried to keep the focus off Khashoggi’s killing and on their big plans for the kingdom.
“It was a tragedy and a very shocking moment for all of us, and I think everyone has to make the decision for themselves,” said Princess Reema bint Bandar Al Saud, who had just given a talk about her work with the Saudi sports authority.
“There are 33 million people in this country who are trying very hard to move this country forward, and we have a very clear vision,” she said. “This is why we are telling people to take the initiative to invest in our future.”
© 2018 New York Times News Service