November 20, 2026

Respected HK broadcaster faces uncertain fate

For decades now, broadcaster Radio Television Hong Kong has held a trusted place in the public eye as a champion of editorial freedom, not unlike the BBC after which it was modelled.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 05 Feb 2007, 03:59 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:21 PM

HONG KONG, Feb 5 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - For decades now, broadcaster Radio Television Hong Kong has held a trusted place in the public eye as a champion of editorial freedom, not unlike the BBC after which it was modelled. RTHK, which functions as a government department with full public funding, is arguably the most liberal and critical public broadcaster operating on Chinese soil today. Its airwaves buzz with talk-show barbs against contentious government policies and human rights cases in China, including the five-year jailing of Singapore Straits Times journalist Ching Cheong on spying charges. Now, some say, a major public broadcasting review initiated by the city's government last year threatens to mute its unique voice and heighten tensions in an already bristling newsroom. Critics call the review an ill-disguised attempt to muzzle RTHK under pressure from conservatives in Beijing, who in recent years have been cracking down on already scant mainland media freedom -- despite some relaxation of rules for foreign reporters in the run-up to the 2008 Olympics. RTHK's struggle to resist becoming a government mouthpiece began in the 1980s during British colonial rule, and is by no means unusual for a public broadcaster, the BBC included. "It's been a sort of incremental struggle to win independence if you like -- just flexing your muscles and doing things," said Cliff Bale, RTHK's head of English news. Pressure from government and hard-line Beijing voices, both explicit and implicit, surfaced especially after sensitive interviews, such as those with Taiwan politicians like Vice-President Annette Lu. But RTHK's present plight mirrors the tensions that have simmered in Hong Kong since the colony reverted to Chinese rule in 1997, and incessant fears that Beijing would further erode the latitude now enjoyed in one of Asia's freest media arenas. Raymond Wong, a veteran former news executive handpicked by the government to head the review committee, parries accusations that there is any hidden censorship agenda. He argues the review will bring a much-needed governance overhaul of a hulking, septuagenarian broadcaster that has suffered through a number of minor corruption scandals. What is being proposed in a final report due in early February, Wong says, is for RTHK to separate fully from the government and instead become "an independent, public broadcasting corporation". "Let's face it, the way RTHK's run right now is untenable," Wong told Reuters in an interview. Funding would still largely come from public purse strings but RTHK might have to stump up as much as a fifth of its operating expenses on its own within 10 years. The liberal nature of those proposals -- some of which were tentatively aired last September -- surprised some media commentators. But persistent delays in releasing the final report originally due at year's end have raised fears of interference. "What we are hearing is that pro-Beijing voices are trying to influence the review committee, and that might be a reason for the delay," said an RTHK staff source on condition of anonymity. But Wong said it would be unwise for the government to attempt this. The government "can either accept the whole thing as it is, they can cherry-pick, or they can throw the damned thing away, which I doubt they'll do because they'll have a hard time explaining it", Wong said. RTHK editorial staff say government officials call the newsroom regularly to challenge reports critical of policies, while offering a more positive spin -- suggestions that sources say have sometimes been taken up. A government source close to Chief Executive Donald Tsang explained the Hong Kong leader's difficulties. "He's fairly relaxed about (RTHK). But he would certainly realise over the years, there's been quite a bit of pressure from certain camps that RTHK should be more of a government mouthpiece and should not be critical, or controversial, particularly when it comes to government policies," the source said. "There's always been this tension," the source added. That tension has sparked notable casualties, among them Mak Yin-ting, a former assignment editor with RTHK's Chinese newsroom, who decided not to renew her contract last year. "I was unhappy at the editorial line being taken," Mak, a former chairwoman of the Hong Kong Journalists Association, told Reuters. Despite this, Mak said the likely separation of RTHK from government could reduce some government interference, but only if RTHK's public funding were guaranteed along with an independent, democratically elected board of governors. "A real, genuine corporatisation is good for RTHK, for public service broadcasting. But I don't think the government will lose its hand in this regard," she said. bdnews24.com/srs/2148 hrs
Related Stories