Price comparison sites—are they independent?
Consumers are confused about what insurance price comparison Web sites offer and how independent they are, research shows.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
11 Jun 2007, 04:31 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 03:24 PM
LONDON, June 11 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Consumers are confused about what insurance price comparison Web sites offer and how independent they are, research shows.
Some 41 percent of 2,184 British adults surveyed mistakenly believe that price comparison services quote all major insurers and 35 percent think they search the entire market.
The poll was commissioned by insurer Direct Line, which is not quoted on price comparison search engines and only sells its products directly.
It also found that 38 percent of people are unaware that these sites make commission on sales, instead believing that they provide a free service or make money solely from selling advertising space.
Just a quarter of consumers are aware that some price comparison Web sites are affiliated to a particular financial group, the research also discovered.
Emma Holyer, a spokeswoman for Direct Line, said: "Consumers are confused about price comparison Web sites and our research shows many believe they provide an independent, public service designed to ensure consumers get the best deal on their insurance.
"Unfortunately, this is not the case, as these Web sites are really just on-line middlemen who make money out of commissions on insurance sales, just like a traditional high street broker."
However, Confused.com, a pioneer of price comparison services in the car insurance market, said online price comparison sites had driven down costs for consumers and insurers alike by simplifying the buying process and making price comparison more transparent.
It said Direct Line, owned by the Royal Bank of Scotland group, is the only major insurance group to consistently refuse to allow such sites to compare its prices with its rivals.
Debra Williams, managing director of Confused.com, which covers 97 percent of the car insurance market, said: "This looks like an act of desperation from an increasingly uncompetitive Direct Line.
"It's a shame it won't allow its quotes to be compared through independent price comparison sites.
"But there may be a reason -- our initial research suggests that nine times out of 10 Direct Line's quotes wouldn't feature in our top five cheapest prices.
"And in some cases, Direct Line doesn't even make the top 10."
bdnews24.com/lq/2206hrs