November 21, 2026

New Bollywood 'Don' scores with fans

A slick remake of a Bollywood classic about murky crime syndicates has been panned by critics but audiences have lapped up the chance to compare a reigning star with a legendary actor in their portrayals of the lead role.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 27 Oct 2006, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 06:45 PM

MUMBAI, October 28 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - A slick remake of a Bollywood classic about murky crime syndicates has been panned by critics but audiences have lapped up the chance to compare a reigning star with a legendary actor in their portrayals of the lead role. 'Don' was this year's most awaited Bollywood remake because it pitched Shah Rukh Khan, whom Time magazine called -- in terms of recognition -- the world's biggest movie star, against Bollywood legend Amitabh Bachchan, named the best actor of the millennium in a BBC online poll. For years, the debate over which of the two is a better actor has engaged Bollywood, and 'Don' offered the perfect opportunity to compare their skills, with Khan taking the role of the gangster first portrayed by Bachchan nearly three decades ago. The film was released to a rousing opening last week but the jury is still out. Critics say the remake is nowhere as good as the original blockbuster and Khan couldn't match Bachchan's gripping performance. Many viewers seem to agree, but nevertheless, the remake is good enough to stand on its own, they say. 'Let's just leave Mr Bachchan's films alone and forget remakes of all those golden oldies,' said film critic Nikhat Kazmi, referring to a recent Bollywood trend to remake yesteryear blockbusters. Bachchan's 'Don', a runaway 1978 hit, told the story of a gangster whose death is kept a secret by police because they want to infiltrate his gang with a look-alike country bumpkin. But the mole runs into trouble when the only police officer who knows his true identity is killed. At the same time his gang also learns the truth and turns against him. Khan's version is almost the same -- with even the same soundtrack remixed -- but the slick, James Bond-style film is mostly shot in Malaysia instead of Mumbai in the older version. 'Let's just say, the new 'Don' is body beautiful, minus soul,' critic and trade analyst Taran Adarsh said. Khan has sought to brush aside the comparison of his film with the older version as 'bullshit'. 'It has to be seen as a film on its own,' the actor told the Times of India newspaper. 'The problem with critics today is that they feel compelled and are in a race to rip a film apart. I go by the audience viewpoint.' The film's box office collection figures for the first week are yet to come in, but with a strong opening and a good response even in overseas markets, the $7-million (3.7 million pound) remake is set to be a hit, industry analysts said. Khan's fans seemed to love seeing their romantic hero transform into a suave gangster carrying a specially crafted gun, high-tech gadgets and a bevy of beauties on his arms. 'It's unfair to watch the film with pre-conceived ideas and cynicism,' said Dinesh Solanki, a businessman who watched 'Don' at the weekend. 'Shah Rukh is good and the end is not the same so one can go expecting a surprise.' bdnews24.com/srs/1428 hrs
Related Stories