Media suit seeks to open EU court filings
A journalists' organisation launched a rare legal challenge to the European Commission on Wednesday, seeking to open up the confidential arguments Brussels submits to the European Union's courts.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
28 Feb 2007, 12:27 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 02:32 PM
LUXEMBOURG, Feb 28 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - A journalists' organisation launched a rare legal challenge to the European Commission on Wednesday, seeking to open up the confidential arguments Brussels submits to the European Union's courts.
Europe's second-highest court was holding an unusual session of its 13-judge Grand Chamber to hear a request by the Brussels-based International Press Association (API) to force the EU executive to make the documents available to the public.
The Commission has long had a policy of confidentiality for all legal briefs filed to the Court of First Instance and the European Court of Justice, the highest EU court.
API asked the Commission in 2003 for access to seven court filings on cases ranging from competition decisions on major business mergers to disputes with member states on transatlantic air travel pacts.
The EU executive released two of the documents for cases it considered closed, but declined to open files on pending cases.
EU rules say the 27-nation bloc's institutions should refuse access to documents if disclosure "would undermine the protection of ... court proceedings and legal advice ... unless there is an overriding public interest in disclosure".
API argues the public has an overriding interest in knowing the Commission's views and in February 2004 it asked the Court of First Instance to order the Commission to open the files.
The journalists contend secrecy makes it difficult for them to provide accurate, comprehensive information on court cases.
The Commission argues that protecting the court from public pressure, which it fears would be generated by publication of the documents, is more important than giving journalists the information.
The Commission notes the court itself has instructed its registrar to make certain no third party sees files without the permission of the court president, and then only after the parties have been heard.
"Parties have the right to defend their interests free from all external influences and particularly from influences on the part of members of the public," the Commission argued, according to a court document released on Wednesday.
The journalists' group said some national courts already make such documents available, excluding business secrets, and none has found its ability to hand down fair rulings impaired.
bdnews24.com/srs/1756 hrs