Iran can harass but not block Hormuz ships: experts
Iran's navy has the power to disrupt but not halt traffic through the Strait of Hormuz, which handles about a third of sea-borne crude oil shipments, defense experts said on Friday.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
23 Mar 2007, 11:21 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 02:44 PM
WASHINGTON, March 24 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Iran's navy has the power to disrupt but not halt traffic through the Strait of Hormuz, which handles about a third of sea-borne crude oil shipments, defense experts said on Friday.
Iran's capture of 15 British sailors on Friday sent US crude oil futures to a three-month high above $62 a barrel, as traders pondered renewed tensions between the world's fourth-biggest crude oil exporter and the West.
Washington-based defence experts say that while Iran can harass ship traffic on the Strait, the OPEC member's ability to crimp oil tanker traffic is extremely limited.
"What you're talking about if Iran forced the issue would be a very unpleasant week for the world oil market and an incredibly unpleasant week for Iran's military forces," said Anthony Cordesman, a Middle East expert at the Centre for Strategic and International Studies.
Iran on Friday captured 15 Royal Navy personnel during a "routine boarding operation" in Iraqi waters, Britain's Ministry of Defence said.
The incident raised tensions between Iran and the West that have already been inflamed by a dispute over Iran's nuclear programme, which Tehran says is for electricity and not for building nuclear weapons.
Though Iran has actively sought a blue-water navy, its forces are still no match for the US Navy's Fifth Fleet and allied forces that have actively patrolled the Persian Gulf for decades, experts said.
"They can bother you, they can raise risks, but at the end of the day we're talking about control, and there is just no question that they do not have that capacity," said David Ochmanek, a senior policy analyst at the RAND Corp. in Washington.
Others disagree. According to congressional testimony this week by Ariel Cohen at the Heritage Foundation, Iran could shut down the Strait by lacing it with anti-ship mines, with "significant, if not disastrous" consequences to energy markets.
According to Cohen's testimony, Iran has a wide variety of weapons to disrupt tanker traffic, including underwater mines and missiles that its Revolutionary Guard warns could sink "big warships."
Revolutionary Guards are also trained to attack ships using attack boats, mini-submarines and even jet skis, and has underwater demolition teams that can attack offshore platforms, Cohen said.
However, experts say Iran's naval capabilities are often overstated. "It's easy to do a laundry list of what they have and make it sound more apocalyptic than it really is," said Joseph McMillan, an analyst at the National Defence University's Institute for National Strategic Studies.
"A frogman and a tanker and a jet ski is kind of a comic book," Cordesman said.
Friday's incident pales in comparison with the "tanker war" that took place in the strait between Iran and Iraq in the 1980s, where each nation fired on each other's oil tankers bound for their respective ports.
But the strait is arguably the most prominent "choke point" in the global crude oil trade. Its 2-mile-wide channel connects some of the biggest Middle East producers like Saudi Arabia with world markets.
The Strait of Hormuz handles 17 million barrels per day of global water-borne crude oil trade, over a third of total global shipments.
"The world has never seen anything close to the size of the Strait of Hormuz closure," said Erik Kreil, an analyst at the US Energy Information Administration.
If the Strait closed down, it would be four times bigger than the largest disruption to date -- the 1991 invasion of Kuwait by Iraq, which shut down about 4.5 million bpd, Kreil said.
bdnews24.com/srs/0423 hrs