November 21, 2026

HK election candidates spar in first TV debate

Two candidates for Hong Kong's leadership traded barbs in the first debate of its kind in the former British colony on Thursday, with the Beijing-backed incumbent, Donald Tsang, scoring higher marks in a snap poll.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 01 Mar 2007, 03:54 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:33 PM

HONG KONG, March 1 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Two candidates for Hong Kong's leadership traded barbs in the first debate of its kind in the former British colony on Thursday, with the Beijing-backed incumbent, Donald Tsang, scoring higher marks in a snap poll. An 800-seat electoral committee will select the city's next chief executive on March 25 in a secret ballot Tsang is widely expected to win by a considerable margin. Respected barrister Alan Leong, who made history last month by qualifying as the first ever pro-democracy challenger in such a leadership contest, challenged Tsang in the televised debate on the economy and plans for full democracy. "My competitor said that he supports people's views and will listen to people's views, but the public is not allowed to come to this venue today," Leong said in his opening remarks, promising universal suffrage by the next election in 2012. "All the people have been contributing to Hong Kong, so how come they do not have this vote?" The public was barred from attending the debate, but several protesters stormed the forum venue before they were ejected by security personnel. Activist legislator Leung Kwok-hung, also known as Long Hair, was thrown out of the hall when he began shouting that it was a 'shameful election'. Tsang, who vowed to 'solve this universal suffrage issue' in the coming five years, attacked Leong for misunderstanding the territory's finances. "I don't think Mr Leong is very clear about public finance," he said. "I hope the financial analysts haven't heard you, otherwise, well, our stock market has dropped a lot and your remarks would make the situation worse." Hong Kong reverted to Chinese rule in 1997 and the members of its election committee are largely sympathetic to Beijing. Despite criticism of Tsang's ineffectual handling of the city's chronic air pollution and glacial progress on democratic reform, Tsang enjoys robust public support. The forum -- first envisioned as a feisty US style presidential debate -- was watered down to bar direct public participation or cross-questioning, reflecting the engrained conservatism of Hong Kong's Beijing anointed ruling elite. In a Hong Kong University survey of some 500 people, the results of which were shown on Hong Kong Cable TV, 65 percent said they would vote for Tsang, while about 21 percent would pick Leong. About 46 percent thought Tsang performed better in the debate while 34 percent thought Leong came out on top. "Alan Leong, because he's a big lawyer, can turn white to black and black to white and so his debating technique and skills are better than Tsang," said elector Chan Wing-kee, a member of China's top parliamentary advisory body, who was at the debate. "But everthing that Tsang said had substance, whereas Leong was all talk," Chan added. Leong said he agreed to the debate as it provided perhaps the only chance to elicit deeper policy commitments from Tsang. There will be another televised debated in mid-March. bdnews24.com/srs/2137 hrs
Related Stories