November 23, 2026

Gold's safe haven status slips, Asia to the rescue?

Gold's rapid retreat of almost 20 percent from its nominal all-time high three weeks ago shows there is a pecking order of safe havens in which the precious metal sits well behind the US dollar.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 26 Sep 2011, 12:49 PM

Updated : 10 Aug 2022, 05:31 PM

SINGAPORE, Sep 26 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Gold's rapid retreat of almost 20 percent from its nominal all-time high three weeks ago shows there is a pecking order of safe havens in which the precious metal sits well behind the US dollar. It may be tempting to push the analysis even further and question if gold is a safe haven from market volatility and fears, or it's just a popular buy among Chinese and Indians worried about inflation. The reasoning for this is that gold's rally this year has been driven primarily by retail investors in China and India, as well as central bank buying. And it may well be Chinese and Indian consumers are enough to rescue gold from falling off the same cliff that oil did after the 2008 crude bubble popped in spectacular fashion in the last global financial crisis. Of course, there has been more to gold's rally in 2011 than Asian buyers with some additional demand from so-called sophisticated investors in the form of paper gold futures and exchange-traded funds, but this pales when compared to the buying in the form of jewellery and bars and coins. Gold surged 35 percent from the start of the year to the Sept. 6 peak, before slumping as the dollar gained when investors sought the ultimate safety of U.S. Treasuries amid fears of a new global recession. Gold has dropped some 14 percent so far this September, its worst monthly performance in almost three years. Of course, part of this is just the recent strength of the US dollar. In euro terms, gold is down about 1.6 percent since its recent peak on Sept.9 and in Australian dollar terms it's down 6 percent since the recent peak on Aug. 22. Bullish gold bets on COMEX were cut by almost 14 percent to 160,322 contracts last week as hedge funds and other speculators rushed for the exits, their haste being aided by an increase in the margin requirements to hold gold lots. The ETFs fared better, with the largest, the SPDR Gold Trust, remaining relatively stable with 1,252 tonnes of the yellow metal at the end of last week. This is down from the Aug. 8 peak of 1,309 tonnes and from the 1,280 that the fund started the year holding. The COMEX Gold Trust, which has been taking market share from the SPDR, ended last week with about 168 tonnes of gold, up from 117 tonnes at the start of the year. Notwithstanding the COMEX Gold Trust's gains, the bulk of additional gold demand this year has come in the form of coins and bars, which saw a 37 percent increase in the first half, and jewellery, which increased 6 percent. These two categories account for about 82 percent of total gold consumption, so any change in their demand profile will certainly impact the overall gold outlook and price. India and China are also the key drivers of bar, coin and jewellery consumption, with India's demand jumping 38 percent in the second quarter of 2011 from the same period a year earlier and China's by 25 percent. Both these countries are currently battling sticky inflation while dealing with large emerging middle classes, anxious to protect their newly acquired wealth. It is very unlikely Chinese and Indian gold demand is being driven by the same concerns occupying the focus of investors in the Western world, and this may just be enough to halt gold's current slide. Are Chinese and Indian consumers likely to curtail their gold purchases in coming months? Maybe, if their economies go into reverse on the back of renewed recession in the developed world, an event that would probably lower their inflation rates as well. But most analysts see China and India continuing strong growth, although maybe not quite as strong as earlier forecasts given the struggles of the developed world. Whether ongoing physical demand for gold will be enough for the metal to find a floor in coming weeks remains to be seen, but we may be witnessing another example of the disconnect between how Asians and Westerners view the current world economy. With the West's seemingly inept and in-fighting politicians spooking investors in developed countries, their counterparts in Asia seem to be adopting a strategy of seeing just low prices will go before they plan to buy again. bdnews24.com/lq/1849h.
Related Stories