November 21, 2026

Germany seeks 'middle way' in EU energy shake-up

Germany pledged to find a 'middle way' on Thursday in European Union efforts to open gas and electricity markets to more competition as EU governments differed over how far to go in a planned energy sector shake-up.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 15 Feb 2007, 12:56 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:26 PM

BRUSSELS, Feb 15 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Germany pledged to find a 'middle way' on Thursday in European Union efforts to open gas and electricity markets to more competition as EU governments differed over how far to go in a planned energy sector shake-up. Energy ministers met in Brussels for the first time since the European Commission proposed measures last month to cut greenhouse gas emissions, boost energy production from environmentally-friendly sources and separate distribution networks from the generation activities of big utility groups. EU states are split on how far to go in separating, or 'unbundling', power generation and distribution businesses. "I support the Commission emphatically in the goal of having more competition and, through that, more favourable prices in Europe," German Economy Minister Michael Glos, whose country holds the EU presidency, told reporters ahead of the meeting. "On the way to meeting that goal, there are the most different of views among the 27 member states. We will come to an agreement on a middle way," he said. Austrian Economy Minister Martin Bartenstein said the Commission's preference for "ownership unbundling," which would require giants such as Germany's E.ON and RWE to sever their generation and distribution activities by selling off one business, did not have ministers' support. "The voices against ownership unbundling were so clear that it's not doable," Bartenstein said, adding that Germany's only choice was to present a watered-down compromise. In a nod to governments that oppose a major shake-up, the EU executive has offered a second option in which utilities hand over management of grid operations while retaining ownership. Energy Commissioner Andris Piebalgs has said the Commission was open to a third idea from France for 'regulatory unbundling' along French lines. Britain calls that option maintaining the status quo. A draft statement prepared for the energy ministers and obtained by Reuters does not endorse a specific plan. Instead it merely calls on the Commission to elaborate on its proposals. Brussels has also proposed that low-polluting renewable sources, such as wind and solar power, should make up 20 percent of the bloc's energy mix by 2020 and that biofuels account for at least 10 percent of fuel used by vehicles by the same year. Ministers are divided on whether to make those targets binding or not. The draft statement leaves that question open. "I am very optimistic that we will succeed in getting this target through," Glos said. He would not say whether ministers would agree to make the targets mandatory or merely indicative. The Commission contends non-binding targets do not work. Germany supports a compulsory target. But Britain says mandatory goals would prevent nations determining their own energy mix and could be counterproductive. At present the EU has a non-binding goal to increase renewable fuels to 12 percent of the energy mix by 2010, but that is likely to be missed. The Commission has also proposed to cut EU greenhouse gas emissions unilaterally by at least 20 percent by 2020 from 1990 levels, with the possibility of raising that to 30 percent if other developed nations join in. EU environment ministers will address those goals at a meeting next week. The Commission's ideas are not legislative proposals at this stage. Once member states signal their backing, Brussels will prepare draft laws, expected to come out later this year. bdnews24.com/srs/1842 hrs
Related Stories