November 21, 2026

Germany faces "rocky road" to forge Muslim council

The stubborn difficulty of integrating Islam into European public life was on full display in Germany this week after government officials and Muslim leaders reported no progress at high-level consultations.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 03 May 2007, 01:40 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 03:01 PM

PARIS, May 3 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - The stubborn difficulty of integrating Islam into European public life was on full display in Germany this week after government officials and Muslim leaders reported no progress at high-level consultations. The so-called Islam Conference, the latest effort by a European country to create an official council to represent its Muslim minority in dealings with the state, ended its second plenary meeting with both sides far apart. Germany, which launched the consultations last September, hopes to find a solution in three years. France needed 14 years of on-and-off talks to create a state-sponsored Muslim Council that many see as a model for other countries. Italy has been trying for three years, without success. "We are at the beginning of a rocky road," commented Interior Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble, host of the one-day meeting in Berlin on Wednesday. Muslim leaders made far more critical comments. "We can't go on aimlessly debating like this," said Ayyub Axel Koehler, head of a new self-appointed umbrella group of Muslim organisations that the politicians consider unrepresentative of all Muslims. Some experts say plans to create state-sponsored councils to represent all Muslims, much as existing bishops' conferences speak for local Catholics, resemble efforts to square a circle. "This is an attempt to create institutions that don't exist in Islam," said Sara Silvestri, a London City University expert on Muslims in Europe. "It's based on Christian models." Islamic and European law don't always match either. German law says members of religious communities must be able to leave them, a step that is normal in Christian churches but unknown in Islam and punished by death in some Muslim countries. The newly founded Coordination Council of Muslims in Germany (KRM), which represents four-fifths of Germany's 2,500 mosques, wants Berlin to consider it the sole spokesman for all Muslims. But Schaeuble says they represent only mosque-goers, a group estimated at 10-15 percent of Germany's 3.2 million Muslims, and has brought non-practising Muslims into the talks. France, whose 5-million-strong Muslim minority is Europe's largest, struggled to create its Council because most Muslims were organised in rival Moroccan, Algerian, Turkish or black African groups. These splits weaken the official Council. Successive governments also differed on whether to include the large Union of French Islamic Organisations, which some rejected because of its links to the Muslim Brotherhood. It was finally included when the Council was launched in 2003. Consultations in Italy have not succeeded in creating a single council for its 1 million Muslims. Efforts there are now focused on drawing up a "charter of values" for Muslims to follow. The latest draft declares facial veils unacceptable, a point some Muslim leaders disputed. Britain, with Europe's third-largest Muslim minority, numbering 1.8 million, prefers to work with self-appointed bodies like the Muslim Council of Britain or create task forces for issues. "Britain has never tried to create an umbrella institution," Silvestri said. "It has a multilateral dialogue with a number of organisations, so it doesn't privilege one over the other." The Netherlands follows a similar strategy, dealing with the two main Muslim organisations as "discussion partners" but not trying to forge one body to represent its 1 million Muslims. bdnews24.com/lq/1912hrs
Related Stories