Foreign retail role worries India's ruling Congress
A letter from one of India's most powerful politicians is placing the operations of foreign retailers like Wal-Mart squarely at the centre of the debate over how big a role foreign investment should play in India's growth.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
07 Feb 2007, 02:50 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 02:22 PM
NEW DELHI, Feb 7 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - A letter from one of India's most powerful politicians is placing the operations of foreign retailers like Wal-Mart squarely at the centre of the debate over how big a role foreign investment should play in India's growth.
The letter, sent by the head of the Congress ruling party Sonia Gandhi to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and leaked by Indian media, expresses concerns about 'the Wal-Mart effect' on domestic retailers.
Excerpts quoted in the media talk of 'the desirability to first study the possible impact of transnational supermarkets on livelihood security of those engaged in small scale operations'.
India's Bharti Enterprises said in November it would form a joint venture with the world's top retailer Wal-Mart Stores Inc operating several hundred stores across the country in five years.
Tesco and Carrefour have also shown interest in entering India and taking advantage of a booming middle class that is a growing proportion of India's more than 1 billion population.
The government would not comment on the letter although a Congress party official confirmed its existence to local media.
On Wednesday the party's spokesman said leaders were looking for steps to protect the country's legions of small shopkeepers to be included in the government's foreign direct investment (FDI) policy for the retail sector.
"We are not for a ban but the Congress party wants safeguards to be put in place before implementation of the FDI policy," Abhishek Manu Singhvi told reporters.
But the leak caused ripples in government and business circles, as well as the ruling coalition, where Gandhi is hugely influential.
"It's a welcome move in the right direction," senior Congress MP P.J. Kurien was quoted as saying in the Economic Times.
Without mentioning the letter, Trade Minister Kamal Nath said on Wednesday that the government would set up a panel of experts to analyse foreign investment and their social impact on India's farmers and villages.
Singh's government relies on support from several leftist parties, including the Commmunist Party which has already opposed any Wal-Mart entry, and Gandhi herself has been taking left-leaning positions in recent months.
Congress is also likely mindful of state elections in the coming months, including in politically-crucial Uttar Pradesh, where protectionist policies play well as in most of rural India.
"People's antennaes should be up," said Abheek Barua, chief India economist at ABN Amro Bank.
"I don't think the Wal-Mart deal will be scuttled at this stage but it could be an issue in future deals. It is a sign of sparring within the government between a pro-reform camp led by the economy ministry and Gandhi's left-leaning strand, which is quite influential," he said.
Foreign retailers are keen to gain access to the India market, but retailers selling more than one brand are only allowed to operate through franchises and licensees or in the wholesale market. Critics say companies like Wal-Mart are entering India through the backdoor.
Singh has proved willing in the past to tone down controversial reforms. Last year, he put on hold all decisions to sell stakes in the country's state-run enterprises, bowing to pressure from the communists and other allies of his coalition.
This year, the government suspended the creation of hundreds of new special economic zones (SEZs) after violent protests from farmers opposing the takeover of valuable land.
The retail controversy could be even more of a political hot potato.
"It could (become a rally point). There is a real problem," said CP Chandrasekhar, professor of economics at New Delhi's Jawaharlal Nehru University.
"Whether it reaches the level of the SEZ protest we have to see. In SEZs it was the question of land here it is a question of livelihood," he added.
bdnews24.com/amt/srs/2041 hrs