November 21, 2026

EU says may escalate India spirits dispute at WTO

India should cut 'extremely high' duties on imported wine and spirits, the European Union's farm commissioner said on Tuesday, warning that the bloc may take the dispute to the World Trade Organisation (WTO).

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 06 Mar 2007, 02:31 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:35 PM

NEW DELHI, March 6 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - India should cut 'extremely high' duties on imported wine and spirits, the European Union's farm commissioner said on Tuesday, warning that the bloc may take the dispute to the World Trade Organisation (WTO). A European Commission report issued last year, prompted by complaints from European producers of whisky and other spirits and wines, found 'clear violations of WTO provisions' and producers are pressing for action. "I am desperately sorry and disappointed to see no cut by India on its extremely high tariffs on wine and spirits," Mariann Fischer Boel told reporters after meeting Indian Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar. "We are considering a possibility of raising dispute settlement at the WTO," she said. Fischer Boel is due to meet Trade Minister Kamal Nath on her trip and asked if she would request New Delhi to cut duties, she replied: 'You can be sure.' India has said in the past that it was looking into the issue and wants to resolve it through dialogue, but there has been no progress so far. The Commission report found a combination of duties and taxes in some Indian states was as high as 550 percent on imported spirits and 264 percent on wines. "These products are not staples, and European exporters have a legitimate interest in being able to supply the Indian market," the EU farm commissioner said. "Could we not leave it up to Indian consumers to decide when to buy domestically produced wines and spirits and when to try something different?" Scotch whisky makers last week asked the Commission to escalate the dispute at the WTO after India left duties on imported wines and spirits untouched in its annual budget despite lowering duties on other imports. If the WTO forms a dispute settlement panel and rules against India, the EU could impose retaliatory tariffs on imports from India. Fischer Boel said she was in favour of negotiations to end the dispute. "They should reduce it to make it in line with WTO commitments. I am definitely in favour of negotiations rather than litigation," she told a news conference. She urged for greater market access and trade between India and the EU while addressing Indian businessmen and policymakers, and added the EU wanted a balanced outcome of the Doha trade negotiations covering all sectors. "All the big players must get serious about cutting trade-distorting domestic support. There must also be real discipline on all forms of export subsidy," she said. The EU wants more from the United States than is visible now, she said. "The current draft of the new farm bill pushes in the right direction but not far enough." Negotiators say a deal needs to be done in 2007 or risk possibly several years of further delay or collapse, undermining confidence in the global trading system. For a deal to be possible, the United States will have to make bigger farm subsidy cuts and the EU will have to go further in cutting agricultural import tariffs. In return, developing states must open their markets to industrial goods and services. bdnews24.com/srs/2011 hrs
Related Stories