November 21, 2026

EU and US trade charges of blocking Bali talks

The European Union and the United States accused each other on Thursday of blocking a deal to launch negotiations on a new global warming treaty as the clock ran down on UN climate talks in Bali.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 13 Dec 2007, 09:08 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 04:46 PM

NUSA DUA, Thu Dec 13,Indonesia (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - The European Union and the United States accused each other on Thursday of blocking a deal to launch negotiations on a new global warming treaty as the clock ran down on UN climate talks in Bali. The United Nations warned the 190-nation meeting, meant to end on Friday, that continuing deadlock meant there was a risk that the talks would collapse "like a house of cards" and take the momentum out of international efforts to slow warming. The December 3-14 Bali talks are split over the guidelines for starting two years of formal talks on a deal to succeed the Kyoto Protocol, a UN pact capping greenhouse gas emissions of all industrial nations, except the United States, until 2012. "We are a bit disappointed that all the world is still waiting for the United States," said Humberto Rosa, Portugal's Secretary of State for Environment. Portugal holds the rotating EU presidency and Rosa is the EU's chief negotiator in Bali. "The U.S. has been using new words on this -- engagement, leadership -- but words are not enough. We need action. (That's the) one main blocking issue," he told Reuters. The United States, Japan, Canada and Australia oppose EU-led efforts to include a non-binding goal for rich nations to cut emissions of greenhouse gases by 25 to 40 percent below 1990 levels by 2020 as a guiding principle for future talks. The United States reaffirmed it would join a new treaty, meant to be agreed in Copenhagen in late 2009 with participation of developing nations led by China and India, but that it was wrong to set any targets prejudging the outcome. NO MAGIC "Those who are suggesting that you can magically find agreement on a metric when you are just starting negotiations, that in itself is a blocking element," said James Connaughton, Chairman of the White House Council on Environmental Quality. "We will lead, we will continue to lead. But leadership also requires others to fall in line and follow," he said. U.S. climate policy is to invest heavily in new technologies such as hydrogen and "clean coal", without Kyoto-style caps. The range of 25-40 percent cuts for rich nations was given in studies by the U.N. Climate Panel this year, which blamed mankind for stoking warming and urged quick action to avert ever more floods, droughts, melting glaciers and rising seas. On the sidelines, climate campaigner and former U.S. Vice President Al Gore, fresh from collecting the Nobel Peace Prize in Oslo with the U.N. Climate Panel, arrived in Bali to give a speech to delegates about the risks of warming. In the past two weeks, the Bali talks have agreed the workings of a fund to help poor nations adapt to climate change and are close to a deal to reward poor nations for slowing deforestation. There are splits on issues such as aid and sharing technology -- such as wind turbines -- with poor nations. "I'm very concerned about the pace of things," said Yvo de Boer, head of the U.N. Climate Change Secretariat. "We are in an all-or-nothing situation in that if we don't manage to get the work done on the future (terms for negotiations) then the whole house of cards basically falls to pieces." He said that any collapse, involving a postponement of a launch of talks to a next meeting in late 2008 in Poland, could undermine momentum this year stoked by worries about warming. But Emil Salim, chief negotiator for talks host Indonesia, said there was still time for a deal and that the negotiations might well run into early Saturday. Negotiators kept their "cards close to their chests until the final day," he told reporters with a smile. "Bali is the beginning of the process. It is not the end. Meaning what you don't get agreement on here, you push it to Poland and the negotiation will continue. So if there is no agreement in Bali, it doesn't mean it's a disaster." Kyoto binds 37 industrialized nations to cut emissions by an average of 5 percent below 1990 levels by 2008-12. Poorer nations, led by China and India, are exempt from curbs and President George W. Bush pulled out in 2001, saying Kyoto would harm the US economy and wrongly excluded goals for developing countries. The United Nations says a Kyoto successor has to be in place by 2009 to give governments time to ratify the new deal by the end of 2012 and to give markets clear guidelines on how to make investments in clean energy technology. bdnews24.com/lq/1506hrs
Related Stories