November 23, 2026

Ellison denounces Rumsfeld's remarks about Nazi appeasers

Keith Ellison, poised to be first Muslim member of US Congress in the 5th Congressional District, has denounced the comments of Secretary of Defence Donald Rumsfeld, who compared critics of the disastrous Iraq war to appeasers of the Nazis in the 1930s.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 13 Sep 2006, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 06:38 PM

Minneapolis, September 14, 2006 (bdnews24.com) - Keith Ellison, poised to be first Muslim member of US Congress in the 5th Congressional District, has denounced the comments of Secretary of Defence Donald Rumsfeld, who compared critics of the disastrous Iraq war to appeasers of the Nazis in the 1930s. Ellison, 43, has to win the election on November 7 to claim his seat. Its loss would be the equivalent of Labour being defeated in the mining valleys of Wales, agencies report Thursday. He has a hard-fought, yet convincing, win in Tuesday's Democratic primary. Ellison expressed his outrage on two counts -- that Rumsfeld's comments are deeply un-American in their disrespect for the right of free speech, and are equally offensive for trivializing the evil of the Nazi regime, which manifested itself most tragically in the Holocaust of Jews and many others. "Donald Rumsfeld's remarks are despicable and are frankly un-American. Above all, they demonstrate the danger the Bush administration is posing to our basic American freedoms, especially the right to speak out when the government is wrong," Ellison said, "This abuse of power within the Bush Administration and their repeated attempts to silence democratic dissent are a fundamental threat to our democracy. I will fight against this abuse of executive power when I am Congress." "I am equally appalled that Secretary Rumsfeld would compare those of us who disagree with the current failed policy in Iraq as similar to Nazi 'appeasers.' The Nazi regime was an unparalleled evil in the twentieth century, culminating the Holocaust of six million Jews and millions of others. The comparison is illegitimate at best," Ellison continued. "As one of the leaders in the Minnesota House in the fight to censure then- Representative Arlon Lindner for remarks that were anti-Semitic, homophobic and denied aspects of the Holocaust, I take this comparison personally. All who care about preserving the truth about the Holocaust should decry a trivialization of this horrible injustice." "Voters of Fifth Congressional District cannot be satisfied by candidates who simply call for Rumsfeld's resignation, as if that would solve the quagmire in Iraq, put an end to torture and halt the ever-greater presidential abuse of power," Ellison said. "Instead, the voters of CD5 know they deserve a representative in Congress who has spoken out firmly against Bush's war since before it began, and who has the courage to stand up every day to challenge the current administration. They deserve a representative who will not allow anyone, including the Bush administration, to belittle the greatest tragedy of the 20th century." "I believe the voters of CD5 know that I have the proven, progressive record and vision that ensure I will be that representative for them. As our member of Congress, I will fight every day to guarantee true freedom of speech and dissent, and justice for all communities that struggle on behalf of truth." bdnews24.com/1412 hours
Related Stories