November 21, 2026

Banks eye slimming plans as risk weight piles on

Banks, fixated on boosting their capital for over two years, may next be forced to trim their balance sheets to stay on the right side of stringent new rules that massively inflate their assets.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 14 Oct 2010, 10:53 AM

Updated : 24 Apr 2022, 05:43 PM

LONDON, Oct 14 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Banks, fixated on boosting their capital for over two years, may next be forced to trim their balance sheets to stay on the right side of stringent new rules that massively inflate their assets. The Basel III rules laid out for banks a month ago held a double whammy: they tightened the definition of what counts as capital, and increased the risk weighting on many assets, cumulatively pressuring the capital ratio, a measure of a bank's strength. Standard Chartered said an increase in risk-weighted assets (RWA) under Basel III would shave its capital ratio and contributed to its need for a $5.3 billion rights issue, unveiled on Wednesday. Banks are worrying about how RWA inflation can be mitigated -- and the impact on earnings, dividends and returns. "It's a trade-off. There's no way out of it, they can reduce their RWA but in doing so, some of the impact will hurt earnings," said Andrew Lim, analyst at Matrix in London. Banks in Europe with big trading asset books such as UBS, Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank and Barclays will be most affected by the new rules. But there is scope for them to mitigate the impact by as much as half by cutting securitisation exposure, opting for exchange-traded rather than over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives or slimming down other parts of the balance sheet. The calculation on risky assets is complex and will not be finalised until G20 leaders meet in Korea next month. The changes are broadly known and banks are offering some clues on the impact, but they may be reluctant to give many more details at third-quarter results over the next month. The changes should almost double UBS's risk-weighted assets, while Credit Suisse's RWA is set to jump over 70 percent and Deutsche Bank's may rise by half. Wall Street rivals like Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley will also be hit, with RWAs potentially rising by about 80 percent. JPMorgan estimates its RWA will be inflated by $400 billion, or 36 percent. ASSETS/REVENUE TRADE-OFF There are three main areas where banks face a surge in RWAs: they will have to apply more stressed assumptions on the market risk of securities; for counterparty risk; and a change in how illiquid exposures are handled, such as securitised products. Their options to limit the rise include running down or selling assets in the riskiest areas or using structured products to move assets off-balance sheet. But each has a price. Moving OTC derivatives onto centrally cleared exchanges will need a margin outlay that will shave profits, for example, while banks are being encouraged to keep a slice of securitisation exposure on deals for clients. Most banks have rebuilt capital to above a new minimum Core Tier 1 ratio of 7 percent laid out by regulators, but much higher RWAs would drag the ratio of many back near the minimum. That could crimp their ability to pay dividends and hurt returns and keep them in capital conservation mode for longer than investors expected. As a result banks will want to limit the balance sheet inflation, especially in countries such as Switzerland and Britain, where capital rules will be made even tougher. "The ability of banks to optimise their balance sheet in a stable regulatory environment should not be underestimated," said Daniel Davies, analyst at Credit Suisse. Banks are wary of raising expectations too high on what they can do, but are saying they will have some success. UBS has provided the most clarity. Its RWA would have jumped to about 400 billion Swiss francs under Basel III rules, from 205 billion. It reckons it can cut that to 300 billion by taking action. That would still be a 46 percent rise, however, and it has warned it won't pay dividends for some time. Credit Suisse said its RWA would also rise to about 400 billion Swiss francs under Basel III from 233 billion and Barclays has said its RWA would rise by 150 billion pounds from 395 billion, but both expect to take mitigating action. "The question investors have is what is the revenue cost of that mitigation," said Jon Peace, analyst at Nomura. "The investment banks are trying to persuade us it will be mitigated with very little revenue attrition and investors are worried it will be more than that," he said. Sceptics say banks may have cut their balance sheets since 2008 but if it was an easy process more would have been done already, and many assets can take years to run off. bdnews24.com/lq/1653h.
Related Stories