November 20, 2026

Are Afghan forces ready to take over security?

NATO allies are expected to endorse a plan at a summit in Lisbon this week to start transferring the security for parts of Afghanistan to the Afghans next year, part of a bold strategy by Kabul to secure the whole country in 2014.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 16 Nov 2010, 11:09 AM

Updated : 24 Apr 2022, 05:47 PM

KABUL, Nov 16 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - NATO allies are expected to endorse a plan at a summit in Lisbon this week to start transferring the security for parts of Afghanistan to the Afghans next year, part of a bold strategy by Kabul to secure the whole country in 2014. Here are some questions and answers about Afghanistan's security forces and whether they are ready to take over: HOW BIG ARE THEY? The Afghan army numbers about 138,000 soldiers, up from 97,000 in November 2009, and there are about 120,000 police officers, up from 95,000 in November 2009, according to NATO figures from October. In January, international donors agreed to expand the army and police force to about 306,000 by October next year, including 171,600 soldiers and 134,000 police. There are also tentative plans to increase the total size of the security forces to 400,000 by 2013, including 240,000 soldiers and 160,000 police. These figures are based on what commanders have said would be the minimum requirement to secure the whole country. But high attrition rates, mainly from desertion and casualties, mean 133,000 more recruits were needed to increase the total number of personnel by 50,000 and hit overall targets, the commander in charge of training, Lieutenant General William Caldwell, said in September. WHO TRAINS THEM AND HOW MUCH DOES IT COST? Since 2002, the United States has provided over $27 billion -- more than half of all aid money -- for training and equipping the Afghan security forces, according to a March report by the U.S. Office of the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction, or SIGAR. Other international donors have made relatively nominal contributions. The police force suffered a serious lack of funding after Germany became the lead nation for building up the force in 2002, spending only $80 million by 2007. In contrast, the US military budgeted $2.5 billion for 2007, when it took over, and a further $800 million for 2008. The Afghan government said it would provide $455 million from March 2010 to March next year, up from $140 million last year, according to a Pentagon report in April. That figure amounts to more than 30 percent of total government spending. Sustaining the army alone will cost about $3 billion a year after October 2011. Training for the army and police is carried out by the new NATO Training Mission-Afghanistan (NTM-A) which combined last year with the Combined Security Transition Command-Afghanistan (CSTC-A), a US military unit, which had been responsible for the bulk of the training. While NTM-A is a multinational mission, the vast majority of the trainers are still American. European Union Police also has several hundred trainers and has extended its mandate for another three years. Some police training is also outsourced to private security firms. Caldwell said last month the alliance was still short of 900 specialist instructors and had begun sending hundreds of recruits to study outside Afghanistan as a stopgap solution. HOW GOOD ARE THEY? The Afghan National Army is seen as a relative success story, especially in comparison to the police. The most common complaint is that there aren't enough of them to hold territory, especially in the violent south, although Western commanders say numbers there have improved. But a May report by the International Crisis Group think tank said too much focus had been placed on quantity and not quality and that combat readiness had been "undermined by weak recruitment and retention policies, inadequate logistics, insufficient training and equipment and inconsistent leadership". The Afghan National Police is seen as inept and corrupt and has long lagged behind training of the army. Police are often the only face of the government in many remote areas and a chronic lack of equipment makes them vulnerable to attack -- police have suffered much higher rates of casualties than the army. Police also usually end up working in their own neighbourhoods, leaving them open to bribes and the influence of local power brokers. Illiteracy as well as drug abuse are also big problems. Only 14-18 percent of current recruits were literate, Caldwell said. ARE AFGHANS READY TO TAKE OVER? At the moment: no. Observers say not only is the 2014 deadline ambitious, but commanders have already scaled back the pace at which they intend to transfer security before then. Rather than handing over an entire province, foreign troops now aim to transfer responsibility to Afghans district by district. The first districts will likely be in the north and west which, although relatively calmer, have seen a spike in violence in the past year. Lieutenant General David Rodriguez, commander of day-to-day operations for US and NATO troops in Afghanistan, told Reuters this month the increase in violence in those areas would not delay the transition. When foreign troops go elsewhere, militants may launch attacks where Afghans have taken over. Commanders say the Afghan army has made strides in recent months and has started leading more operations. However, in March, SIGAR said previous systems used to assess the security forces had led to their operational capabilities being overstated. Only 23 percent of soldiers and 12 percent of police were able to work without the help of foreign troops, it said Most ordinary Afghans agree. An Asia Foundation survey this month found that while 92 percent of people surveyed said they had confidence in the army and 79 percent in the police, more than two-thirds said they could not operate alone. Caldwell has said handover targets won't be met if more trainers aren't sent. bdnews24.com/lq/1707h.
Related Stories