November 21, 2026

US Congress may revoke FBI's power to eavesdrop

It looks as though the pendulum is beginning to swing back from its current position on the far right of the scale as both Democrat and Republican politicians in the US, in an unusual display of bi-partisan accord, warn the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) that it is in danger of having its authority to "Hoover-up" massive amounts of telecoms, email and other communications-based personal data severely curtailed after discovery of widespread abuses of its powers.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 01 Apr 2007, 02:10 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:49 PM

Martyn Warwick London, April 1 (bdnews24.com) -- It looks as though the pendulum is beginning to swing back from its current position on the far right of the scale as both Democrat and Republican politicians in the US, in an unusual display of bi-partisan accord, warn the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) that it is in danger of having its authority to "Hoover-up" massive amounts of telecoms, email and other communications-based personal data severely curtailed after discovery of widespread abuses of its powers. Glenn Fine, a senior official at the US Justice Department recently submitted a 130-page report to the House Judiciary Committee revealing that the FBI routinely misused its authority illegally to collect, maintain and manipulate data on US citizens and foreigners alike via a mechanism called "National Security Letters" (NSL). NSLs give the FBI the power acquire e-mails, telephone, travel records and financial information on US citizens and foreigners alike, and indeed on anyone deemed to be "under suspicion". In his summing-up to the House Judiciary Committee, Mr. Fine said that the FBI's "failure to establish sufficient controls or oversight for collecting the information constituted serious and unacceptable failures". Democrats on the Committee immediately cited his findings a prime example of how the FBI and other agencies have used broad–brush counter-terrorism legislation and authority delegated via those laws to drive a coach and horses through the privacy rights of US citizens – in breach of the US Constitution. John Conyers, a Michigan Democrat and the Committee chairman commented that the FBI's action "was a serious breach of trust" and added "The Justice Department had converted this tool into a handy shortcut to illegally gather vast amounts of private information while at the same time significantly underreporting its activities to Congress." As part of his investigation, Glenn Fine reviewed files selected from within the FBI headquarters in Washington DC and from four of the agency's 56 field offices. From these Mr. Fine uncovered 48 violations of US law or presidential directives that had taken place between 2003 and 2005 alone. These included failure by the FBI to obtain proper authorisation for surveillance and interception of electronic communications, making improper requests for such authorisations and the unauthorised collection of phone and/or Internet e-mail records. In addition, Mr. Fine reported that "a significant number of .... violations throughout the FBI have not been identified or reported." Concern that the FBI has been running out of control and oversight is not confined solely to the Democrats. Republicans too are worried that rights guaranteed under the Constitution are being ignored, circumvented and eroded. Dan Lungren, a California Republican, told the FBI that it must move quickly to correct its "mistakes" and said that if things aren't sorted out with "extreme speed" the agency "probably won't have recourse to National Security Letters any more." Another Californian Republican, Darrell Issa was even more blunt, he told the Justice Department and the FBI, ""From the attorney general on down, you should be ashamed of yourselves. We stretched to try to give you the tools necessary to make America safe, and it is very, very clear indeed that you have abused that trust." A suddenly galvanised FBI has launched an audit of all of its 56 field offices in an effort "to determine the full extent of the problem" and FBI Director Robert Mueller is likely to face some aggressive and determined questioning when he appears before Congress on March 27. The root of the present worries about the FBI overstepping its remit is a direct result of the welter of new law enforcement powers that were granted to various US federal agencies in the immediate aftermath of the terrorist attacks in New York City and Washington DC on September 11, 2001. In the superheated atmosphere of fear, paranoia, patriotism and determination that followed those terrible events, legislation was enacted with extreme speed and without the usual "fine-tooth comb" scrutiny of each and every line, comma and full stop that usually accompanies the passing of new laws in the US. And, ever since, some legislators, administrators and sectors of the US population at large have been expressing worries that laws passed in haste will be repented at leisure as it becomes evident that, in an effort to forestall any further such atrocities, civil rights and liberties gained over centuries of struggle have been sacrificed on the altar of expediency. It was back in 1986, that the US Congress, for the first time, gave permission for the FBI to obtain electronic records and data without first gaining approval written authorisation from a judge. That relaxation issued in the short-cut of the National Security Letter system that has since been so routinely abused. With the passing of the Patriot Act in 2001, even that fig leaf was removed as the Act did away with any requirement that the records being accessed should belong to a person "under suspicion." So, for getting of for six years past, records and data pertaining to completely innocent people have been obtained by FBI staff on the grounds that individual agents believe them to be tangentially "relevant" to an investigation no matter how remotely "connected" to terrorism or espionage. Congress itself authorised Glenn Fine's investigation in the teeth of a barrage of objections raised by the Bush administration, and his report shows that the number of National Security Letters issued once the Patriot Act became law, "went through the roof". Mr. Fine describes more than 700 cases in which FBI agents obtained telephone records through what he terms "exigent letters" in which FBI staff claimed that grand jury subpoenas had been requested for the data, when in fact no such subpoenas had ever been sought. And now it seems Congress is on to the FBI's tricks and is minded to revoke some of the agency's powers as a result. Directly addressing the FBI on this, Darrell Issa said that if the agency's powers are revoked, "America may be less safe, but the Constitution will be more secure, and it will be because of your failure to deal with this in any serious fashion." Meanwhile Jerrold Nadler, a New York Democrat, said Congress should revise the Patriot Act, the legislation that relaxed controls over National Security Letters. He said, "We do not trust government always to be run by angels, especially not this administration. But it is not enough to mandate that the FBI fix internal management problems and record-keeping, because the statute itself authorises the unchecked collection of information on innocent Americans." However, other Republicans, whilst acknowledging that the FBI has over-reached itself on occasion, believe the agency should be allowed to retain its expanded powers as they are "vital to maintaining homeland security." Thus Lamar Smith, the senior Republican on Committee, opined, "The problem is with enforcement of the law, not with the law itself." Glenn Fine says he does not believe the breaches he has uncovered were "intentional", although he does acknowledge that deliberate intent to abuse powers "cannot be ruled out." Addressing the Committee he said, " It really was unacceptable and inexcusable what happened but we believe the misuses and the problems we found generally were the product of mistakes, carelessness, confusion, sloppiness lack of training, lack of adequate guidance and lack of adequate oversight." Some on the panel completely disagree with his rather benign analysis. As for the FBI itself, Valerie Caproni, the agency's general counsel, said she takes responsibility for the abuses and will eradicate them "within a matter of months." Martyn Warwick is the Editor-in-Chief of telecomTV in London. bdnews24.com/ask/ad/2005 hours
Related Stories