Published : 07 Sep 2015, 11:17 AM
Updated : 19 Oct 2022, 06:56 PM
De Rossi scored with a twice-taken penalty in the sixth minute but blotted his copybook early in the second half when he was dismissed after clashing with Iliyan Mitsanski, who was also sent off.
Buffon, who won his first cap in a World Cup qualifier away to Russia in 1997, rescued Italy with a difficult save from Giorgi Milanov in stoppage time.
The win took Italy top of Group H with 18 points from eight games and kept them on course for a top-two finish which would ensure a place in France next year.
They are followed by Norway (16) and Croatia (15) while Bulgaria are fourth with eight points and two games left.
"We dominated the game and deserved to score more goals," coach Antonio Conte told Rai television. "I'm disappointed that the result was in the balance until the end, you always run the risk of getting an unlucky rebound.
"I didn't see the De Rossi incident but if he retaliated, then he's made a mistake, because he could have put everything at risk."
Playmaker Andrea Pirlo was left out as Conte made several changes following his team's much-criticised, lacklustre performance in their 1-0 win over Malta on Thursday.
Italy nearly went ahead in the first minute when Graziano Pelle's shot as saved by Bozhidar Mitrev and Stephan El Shaarawy tried to score with an overhead kick from the rebound but sent his effort over the bar.