Cricket-Insensitivity leads to Hair's downfall
Even his worst enemies among the Asian players he offended during 14 years as a test umpire would concede that Darrell Hair possessed the courage of his convictions.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
04 Nov 2006, 06:00 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 06:47 PM
By John Mehaffey
LONDON, Nov 4 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Even his worst enemies among the Asian players he offended during 14 years as a test umpire would concede that Darrell Hair possessed the courage of his convictions.
The brawny, 53-year-old Australian, whose international umpiring career ended abruptly on Saturday when he was banned until his contract expires in March 2008, never avoided the tough calls.
Conversely, he never acquired the diplomatic skill that would have defused potentially explosive situations.
His strengths and his weaknesses were highlighted in the Oval test in August which precipitated the downfall of the fourth most experienced test umpire in history after 76 tests and 121 one-day internationals.
On the fourth day of the fourth test between England and Pakistan, Hair and his colleague Billy Doctrove concluded that the tourists had tampered with the ball.
Without telling captain Inzamam-ul-Haq, the umpires penalised Pakistan five runs and changed the ball.
The outraged Pakistanis, who blamed Hair for the decision, protested by refusing to take the field after the tea interval and the umpires subsequently ruled they had become the first test side to forfeit a match.
Hair's future appeared, at best, problematic when the International Cricket Council (ICC) revealed in the same month that he had offered to retire in exchange for $500,000.
In the following month his fate was effectively sealed when an inquiry cleared Inzamam of ball-tampering and on Saturday ICC president Percy Sonn said Hair would not be allowed to umpire again before his contract expired.
Hair first attracted international attention in 1995 when he no-balled Sri Lanka off spinner Muttiah Muralitharan seven times for throwing at the Melbourne Cricket Ground.
Subsequently he called Zimbabwean part-time left-armer Grant Flower and questioned the actions of Pakistan pace bowlers Shoaib Akhtar and Shabbir Ahmed.
Although there were other decisions which angered India, South Africa and England, it was the throwing issue with its implication that the bowler was cheating which created the most controversy.
Hair remained unrepentant and in his 1998 autobiography "Decision Maker" he said Muralitharan had a "diabolical action".
One accusation Hair has angrily rejected is the suggestion that his decisions have been motivated by racism.
"It really upsets me when people describe me as a racist because they have no idea how I spent my childhood and how that shaped my beliefs," he told Britain's Mail on Sunday.
"How can people judge me to have prejudices when I went to school in Australia alongside Chinese children, Hungarian refugees and all manner of other nationalities?"
Hair's strength of mind was revealed in full at a Sept. 28 news conference at The Oval after the announcement that Inzamam had been cleared of ball-tampering but found to have brought the game into disrepute.
The Australian did not need to face an audience bound to contain hostile elements. Not only did he agree to being questioned but he also declined an opportunity to cut short the news conference.
"I don't have any problems umpiring in any part of the world," he said. "If we can't take the criticism we shouldn't be out there. I've handled it for 21 years and can still handle it when it's justified and when it's not justified."
As he was to answer questions, Hair also made it clear when he thought an inquiry was stupid with dismissive responses that alienated those in the audience he had begun to win over.
Ultimately, it was this lack of sensitivity that led to the premature end of his career.
bdnews24.com/ma/aak/1150 hrs