November 21, 2026

'Wrap up quizzing by Wed noon'

Salauddin Quader Chowdhury's lawyer was not feeling well and desired for another one hour and a half Updates

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 10 Jul 2012, 08:22 AM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:00 PM

Dhaka, Jul 10 (bdnews2four.com) — The first war crimes tribunal of Bangladesh on Tuesday ordered the defence to complete the ongoing cross-examination of a prosecution witness against BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury by Wednesday noon. Set up to try crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, the three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1 indicted the six-time MP from Chittagong on Apr 4 for 23 war crimes. The tribunal Chairman, Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq passed an order to close the day's proceedings noting that the defence counsel Ahsanul Huq had indicated he would need at least four sessions although the court had granted him three. Furthermore, the order noted that the counsel questioned the sixth prosecution witness until about 3:30pm on Monday, half an hour short of the usual closing time. On Tuesday, the order said cross-examination had been proceeding smoothly but the counsel was not feeling well and still had some more material to cover. The order noted that the counsel desired for another one hour and a half. As such, Justice Huq said the court was inclined to give the defence another 90 minutes from 10:30am on Wednesday. And with that the matter was adjourned. The tribunal has been watchful about the time and set a time limit for both the deposition and cross-examination of Nirmal Chandra Sharma, the sixth prosecution witness. Justice Huq said in his order that although the tribunal thought under normal circumstances cross-examination should not exceed double the length of time taken for deposition, the court had decided upon three sessions – instead of two – "considering the gravity of the statements" made by the witness. SQ Chy counsel 'reacts ' The tribunal has been insisting that the defence proceed quickly and wrap up the cross-examination by the end of the day. There were several exchanges to that effect amid banter off and on at certain points of cross-examination. Tribunal member Justice Anwarul Haque once asked the defence counsel when he would give his trademark suggestion 'You have given a false testimony, in a false case', which typically marks the end of his cross-examination. "Not until tomorrow," Ahsanul Huq had said. "But we are all waiting for that!" said the judge. The counsel continued his cross-examination. The judges urged him to proceed at certain points and the tribunal chair also told the lawyer that the court expected cross-examination to be completed within the day. Every time the counsel indicated that he would require the morning session on Wednesday. However, Ahsanul Huq took exception when at the close of the day, the tribunal Chairman insisted that he complete the questioning and further said that he would have pass an order by the end of the day. "I cannot proceed if you are there with a whip in your hand!" said the counsel. "No, I am not used to doing things in this manner," he said gathering up his papers and giving every indication to stop for the day. Justice Huq's disappointment was quite evident from the grave tone his voice had acquired by the time he replied. "Mr Ahsanul Huq, we have passed the order according to the act and the rules." The tribunal chief pointed out that the court had passed an order stipulating the time limit and now that the third session was going to expire, the court would have to pass another order. "It is quite normal and there is no reason to become angry," he said and trailed off saying "but the way you have reacted..." with a disapproving shake of his head. The defence counsel said he was not angry. "But I am a human being! And it is almost 4pm after a long day. And we have also lost some time," said Ahsanul Huq who had been conducting cross-examination throughout the day. "Would you like us to pass the order now?" asked the tribunal chief. "Yes," came the short reply. "It could go either way," cautioned Justice Huq. Tribunal member Judge A K M Zaheer Ahmed managed to cajole the counsel into continuing. "Why don't you at least go on until 4:30pm and then we shall see. Do continue until then, and if you are not done, we will see." Ahsanul Huq then resumed his cross-examination and indicated that he was going to wrap it up within the day. The tribunal, however, observed that the defence was not looking well. "Sit down and have a drink of water," said Justice Huq. The tribunal chair had to repeat himself several times before Ahsanul Huq took his seat. The tribunal then asked how long the counsel would need and Ahsanul Huq said at first two hours and then said he would be done within another hour and a half. The tribunal then passed the order to that effect. 'Don't remember' Earlier during the cross-examination, the sixth prosecution witness who had miraculously survived an execution of his family came up with the same answer saying either that he 'could not tell' or that he 'could not remember'. The witness, a lawyer of the Chittagong bar, had been lined up with his mother, father, younger brother, two uncles and a nephew. His father became crippled for life after Pakistani soldiers, where Salauddin Quader Chowdhury had also been present, had fired upon them. The others died. Ahsanul Huq asked the witness where he passed his school finals from and the witness said, "Gahira High School." The witness is from the same area after which the school is named. The counsel then asked where he took his 12th grade finals from, meaning Higher Secondary Certificate Examinations. The witness said, "I don't remember." Defence counsel: "Graduation?" Witness: City College. Defence counsel: Which year? Witness: Don't remember. Defence counsel: Where did you get your law degree from? Witness: Don't remember Defence counsel: You had fled to another village after surviving the execution on the morning of Apr 13 in 1971. Where did you go? Witness: To an aunt's (mother's sister), who lived in the Gorduara village. Defence counsel: Can you name the aunt and uncle? Witness: Don't remember. Ahsanul Huq asked the witness a number of other questions probing into details of the deposition. The defence counsel suggested that the brother who Nirmal claims to have lost in the execution had not died at all. "In fact he lives in India." "Not true," said the witness. "Your brother Sunil has two children named Gopal and Amrita," suggested the counsel. "Not true," replied the witness. Mobile rings again A mobile phone rang out during the cross-examination of the witness and this time it was from Prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum's pocket. Justice Huq said, "If you have to answer that, go out. The door is always open." Malum happens to be the conducting prosecutor of the case against BNP leader Salauddin Quader and he was sitting at the front row when his call came. Embarrassed, the prosecutor stood up and said, "I have silenced it my lord." There was no further discussion and proceedings continued. Another prosecutor, Mir Iqbals Hossain's cell phone had also ringed out on Jul 2 when he stood up to apologise to the court. The tribunal Chairman has already ordered everyone in his courtroom to leave the cellphones outside when they came in. Justice Huq had expressly said that the order was applicable for everyone including the police personnel and the prosecutors. Other matters The tribunal in the morning also allowed a petition from Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee's defence pleading that he be allowed home-cooked food at the hospital where he is recuperating from a heart procedure. Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq said he would, however, impose certain conditions similar to a previous order passed in Ghulam Azam's case. That order has yet to be executed. At the second tribunal the second prosecution witness against Jamaat Assistant Secretary General Abdul Quader Molla, Shahidul Haque Mama, gave his deposition. It was completed before lunch and Mohammad Ekramul Huq took up the cross-examination afterwards. It remained incomplete as the court adjourned for the day. bdnews24.com/ta/bd/2213h
Related Stories