November 20, 2026

Stern telling-off marks start

Tuesday's proceedings at the ICT begins with tribunal chairman justice Nizamul Huq sternly admonishing defence counsellor Fariduddin Khan

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 03 Jan 2012, 03:16 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 03:15 PM

Dhaka, Jan 3 (bdnews24.com) — Tuesday's proceedings at the war crimes tribunal began with the tribunal chairman, justice Nizamul Huq, sternly admonishing defence counsellor Fariduddin Khan. The ninth witness in a case against Jamaat executive council member Delwar Hossain Sayedee was expected to depose on the day, followed by his cross examination. Khan had apparently refused to accept formal charges against Abdul Kadar Molla, an assistant secretary general of the Jamaat-e-Islami when the registrar refused to provide him a copy of the investigation report. M Tajul Islam, one of the lawyers representing the Jamaat leaders currently behind bars charged with war crimes during the 1971 Liberation War, stood up to assist his colleague. The tribunal chairman pointed out that the defence would get all the documents that the prosecution would rely upon, in building a case against the accused. "There is a clear list of documents that the defence is allowed." Tajul countered, saying that the law did not prohibit the tribunal from providing the investigation report. He argued, "Since the tribunal takes cognisance of a charge on the basis of the investigation and since the formal charges are also based on this very report, what is the harm in the defence getting a copy?" "But the law must allow it first," said Huq. Tajul Islam seized the opportunity to argue his case once again although a formal petition in the ongoing case against Jamaat leader Sayedee had already been rejected. The defence then said that another accused, BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury, also a former prime ministerial adviser, had been furnished with his investigation report. The tribunal chief smiled and said that it was either a mistake or not true in the first place. "Whatever the case, we will take care of that." Tajul continued with his protestations arguing that tribunal could in fact use its inherent powers to allow the report to be given to the defence. Prosecutor Syed Haider Ali stood up to say that such a petition had already been rejected. "But if the defence really wants the investigation report, then it should file a review petition and the tribunal can then decide." Tajul Islam said that the defence did not file the review petition, "Only because then the prosecution would be up on its feet saying that it is nothing but a waste of time." He said it was a matter that might be resolved in the court room without the formal process and that was the whole point of the discussion. The tribunal chairman then called Fariduddin Khan to come forward but Tajul Islam persisted even though Nizamul Huq had told him, "Yes, yes we have heard you," indicating that he should stop. But when Tajul did not, Huq cut him off, "Mr Tajul Islam, will you stop?" Nizamul Huq then charged Fariduddin Khan, "Why did you refuse to accept the formal charges? You cannot just say that you won't accept them pending the investigation report!" Fariduddin's meek explanation was cut short again. Nizamul Huq said, "I do not want my advocates showing temper at the offices because I hold them in a higher esteem." The matter was brought to a close with that and the ninth witness in a case against Delwar Hossain Sayedee was brought for deposition. And then it was the prosecution's turn. At one point during the cross-examination when the witness failed to understand a question about him meeting freedom fighters, the prosecution tried to argue that it was being put in a roundabout manner. The tribunal had by then told the prosecution to keep quiet during the cross-examination once in the face of protests from the defence who had told the tribunal that the prosecution was interfering with the cross-examination. At this point in the middle of a discussion between prosecutor Haider Ali and the tribunal, one of the prosecutors was heard saying, "Oh but he has!" This wiped off any hint of the light hearted conversation he was having, for the prompt was obviously to lead the witness and the defence instantly objected to it. Judge Justice A K M Zaheer Ahmed continued in the same light tone of the conversation, telling the prosecution that this was not at all desirable. Nizamul Huq then addressed Haider Ali, who was presumably leading the prosecution in the absence of the chief prosecutor Ghulam Arieff Tipoo, "We want your proper action in this respect." The cross-examination continued. When asked what action he might take, Ali told bdnews24.com, "It is nothing like that. The judge had said that because of a momentary lapse of discipline in the courtroom." He said he would speak to his colleagues accordingly so that there is no such recurrence. bdnews24.com/ta/bd/2112h
Related Stories