November 20, 2026

Speaker asks MPs to soften

He requests them to withdraw their proposal for removing a High Court judge and hoped the Chief Justice will act to that end. Updates

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 18 Jun 2012, 01:09 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 03:54 PM

Dhaka, Jun 18 (bdnews24.com)— Speaker Abdul Hamid on Monday requested MPs to withdraw their proposal for removing a High Court judge, saying he too was disappointed with the comment the judge in question had made against him. The much-awaited ruling of the Speaker came during ongoing parliament session, in a bid to douse the tension building following remarks traded between the ruling coalition MPs and Justice AHM Shamsuddin Choudhury. The incident threatened to boil into a full-blown confrontation between Parliament and the Judiciary. The Speaker expected that the Chief Justice himself would initiate measures to that end and the Parliament would support the decision that he will take. Hamid, a lawyer by training, hoped that merely a comment from a judge would not lead to the situation in which the Judiciary is pitted against Parliament. "We all have to keep it in mind that the country is not Pakistan now, it is Bangladesh. I repeat Bangladesh." It all began with the High Court judge criticised the Speaker for a statement he had delivered in Parliament on May 29. Urging the High Court to review one of its orders asking Roads and Highways Department to give back the court a piece of land, the Speaker, on that day, had said, "People may stand up to the judiciary if they feel aggrieved by the verdict of the court." On Jun 5, Justice Choudhury termed the Speaker's statement 'seditious,' drawing flak from ruling coalition MPs the same day. The MPs demanded formulation of Supreme Judicial Council for taking action against the judge and threatened to invoke Parliament's power to impeach judges if their demand was not immediately met. Later, Deputy Speaker Shawkat Ali had said that the Speaker would come up with a ruling, which came at the very beginning of day's parliament session on Monday in presence of Prime Minister and Parliament Leader Sheikh Hasina. "I doubt whether a man with conscience could pass such a remark like the one an honourable judge of the High Court has made against Parliament and me in violation of article 78 of the Constitution," the Speaker said. "At the beginning he said that my statement was tantamount to sedition. The learned judge would have shown his wisdom had he thought deeply about what sedition is, what constitutes sedition, and who should decide the issue of sedition." Addressing the MPs who castigated Justice Choudhury for making the comment, the Speaker said," We should not judge the whole judiciary going by the attitude of an individual. If you all decide about something, it becomes binding on me." "On overall consideration, since I do not believe taking such a stringent measure will be appropriate, I will humbly request you to withdraw the proposal you raised by agreeing with me." Underlining continuation of an reciprocal relation among three parts of the state, Hamid said, "The country is making progress despite having an uneven road to travel in its way just because of this relation." "The bond of this relation should be strengthened for the welfare of the country and the state, this is the expectation of the countrymen," he added. Speaker explains his statement Explaining the circumstances in which he had made the May 29 statement, Hamid said, "On that day, after MP Moyeen Uddin Khan Badal had given a speech about court, I said smiling, 'I will have to return to the court wearing black gown once my speakership expires. So, statements have to be made considering circumstances. I don't know what problem awaits me. I may not get relief by going to conduct case'." "Later, while making the issue of everyone's accountability to the people clear, I had said, 'People may take a stand against us if the laws being passed in Parliament go against their interest. People may stand up against the judiciary if they feel aggrieved by the verdict of the court." The Speaker said, "I had spoken about working for the welfare of the country and the people by dispensing with self-pride. No statement was made targeting either any specific court or case or any particular judge. I only talked about my assumption of what may happen if the three parts of the state do not function properly." bdnews24.com/sum/eh/bd/2052h
Related Stories