November 23, 2026

Shafique, Huda trade salvos over SC authority

Law minister Shafique Ahmed and BNP vice-president Nazmul Huda have fiercely argued over the authority of the court to repeal any constitutional matter approved in parliament.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 21 May 2011, 04:05 PM

Updated : 10 Aug 2022, 04:50 PM

Dhaka, May 21 (bdnews24.com) – Law minister Shafique Ahmed and BNP vice-president Nazmul Huda have fiercely argued over the authority of the court to repeal any constitutional matter approved in parliament. At a discussion at Dhaka University's Senate Building on Saturday, the two Supreme Court barristers mainly argued over the legality of the laws enforced during the martial law regimes. Huda, a former communications minister, said the higher court has been delegated the authority to quash any law that runs contrary to the constitution. "But how can the High Court rescind since an amendment carried out during the military regime that has been included to the constitution through parliament?" he questioned. Huda, also the former president of the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA), referred to the High Court verdicts that declared the Fifth and Seventh Amendments to the constitution illegal. The High Court recently declared illegal all the military laws and orders enforced during the regime of late military ruler Ziaur Rahman, also the founder of BNP. The Supreme Court also upheld the High Court verdicts. The military regime of dictator Hussein Muhammad Ershad also met the same fate. In his response to Huda, law minister Shafique said nowhere does the constitution talk about martial law. So, if all the parliament members together enforce martial law or declare it legal, it can not be constitutional. "So, the higher court indeed has the authority to declare the martial law illegal," said Shafique, also a former SCBA president. Shafique said through military rules, actions contradicting the main pillars of the original constitution were pushed through parliament on the back of two-thirds majority. "The Supreme Court is the guardian of the constitution. So it certainly has the authority to revoke the martial law," he argued. Before that, Huda alleged that the government had influenced the court in declaring the Fifth and Seventh Amendments illegal. "The government had the Fifth and Seventh Amendments repealed by appointing A B M Khairul Haque as chief justice. What they can not do politically they have that done by the High Court," Huda alleged. Center for Practical Multimedia Studies (CPMS) of the university organised the seminar titled 'Freedom of expression: conflicting rights in Bangladesh and some other countries'. Assistant professor of journalism department of Norway's Oslo University Dr Christian Sker Orgaret read out the keynote paper at the seminar. Chaired by assistant professor of the mass communication and journalism department Fahmidul Haque, DU vice-chancellor A A M S Arefin Siddique, pro-vice-chancellor Harun-or-Rashid, general secretary of Asiatic Society Mahfuza Khanam and DU Teachers Association president professor Anwar Hossain, among others, also spoke at the meeting. bdnews24.com/corr/skb/bd/1853h
Related Stories