SCBA plans to file case against Chief Justice
The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) plans to file a case against the Chief Justice for 'arbitrarily' and 'unreasonably' reconstituting the High Court benches.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
27 Jun 2005, 06:00 PM
Updated :
18 Aug 2022, 11:37 AM
Dhaka, June 28 (BDNEWS) – The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) plans to file a case against the Chief Justice for 'arbitrarily' and 'unreasonably' reconstituting the High Court benches.
An urgent general meeting of the SCBA Tuesday provided all powers to its executive committee to take necessary steps, including legal measures, in this regard.
SCBA secretary advocate Enayetur Rahim told BDNEWS that the SCBA will file the case after discussing with the senor lawyers of SCBA.
The meeting in its resolution said the Chief Justice recently changed the jurisdiction of some High Court benches immediately after those benches had issued rules or passed orders in some touchy cases.
"Jurisdictions of all kinds of writ motions of a bench comprising Justice Shah Abu Nayeem Mominur Rahman and Justice Mainul Islam Chowdhury were withdrawn immediately after the bench issued a rule in a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) on June 18," the resolution said.
The High Court, on June 18, had issued a rule upon Chief Election Commissioner Justice MA Aziz to show cause as to why his holding of the office of a judge of the Appellate Division and simultaneously the office Chief Election Commissioner should not be declared illegal and without lawful authority.
The SCBA demanded that the Chief Justice should follow fair and right rules in constituting the High Court benches through discussions and consultations with the judges of the Supreme Court and SCBA leaders.
In the meeting, Bangladesh Bar Council vice president Barrister Rokanuddin Mahmud said by arbitrarily constituting the benches, the Chief Justice has violated the constitution and laws, and illogically interfered in the matter of working independently by the High Court benches.
"If a judge passes any lawful order being run by conscience and if the Chief Justice does not like that order, the Chief Justice cannot change the bench. An attempt of enchaining the judges' legs is going on through the Chief Justice. The Chief Justice cannot apply his power of changing the benches in an autocratic, illogical and politically-motivated manner," he said.
He said what is now taking place in the Supreme Court is very 'unfortunate'.
"The Chief Justice gave motion powers to junior judges, including his brother, overlooking the senior ones. We have to find out at whose instigation the Chief Justice is doing all these things. We want that the Chief Justice applies his administrative powers as per laws and rules, not with political intention," he said.
Barrister Rokan told the meeting that cases will have to be filed challenging the validity of arbitrarily reducing the jurisdictions of judges.
"Justice Shah Abu Nayeem Mominur Rahman was cornered by withdrawing his powers for passing an order in a writ petition filed by advocate Abdus Salam Mamun, an unconfirmed judge, against the Chief Justice. The exploited judges will have to be made parties in the cases and their submissions will have to be heard. We are the voices of the exploited judges," he said.
Barrister M Amir-ul Islam, convener of Sammilita Ainjibi Samannay Parishad, said article 102 of the constitution has been violated through withdrawal of the jurisdiction of a High Court bench.
"The scenarios remind that an attack can be made on the constitution," he said.
Former SCBA president Barrister Shafique Ahmed said by arbitrarily reconstituting a High Court bench, the Chief Justice has interfered in the independence of other judges.
Presided over by SCBA president advocate Mahbubey Alam, the meeting was addressed, among others, by former SCBA president advocate Abdul Baset Majumder, senior advocates ABM Nurul Islam, Mohammad Abdul Halim, Rafiqul Islam Miah and SCBA secretary advocate Enayetur Rahim.
BDNEWS/1937 hrs