SC issues contempt rule against 4 secretaries on judiciary separation case
The Supreme Court (SC) Monday issued a contempt rule against four secretaries of the government for not complying with its 12-point directives on the separation of judiciary from the executive.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
02 Apr 2006, 06:00 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 06:01 PM
Dhaka, Apr 3 (BDNEWS) – The Supreme Court (SC) Monday issued a contempt rule against four secretaries of the government for not complying with its 12-point directives on the separation of judiciary from the executive.
The court asked the four top bureaucrats - Principal Secretary to the Prime Minister Dr Kamal Uddin Siddiqui, Law Secretary Alauddin Sarder, Establishment Secretary Dr Mahbubur Rahman and Finance Secretary Siddiqur Rahman - to explain within three weeks as to why contempt charges should not be brought against them.
The rule was issued by the full bench of the Appellate Division comprising Chief Justice Syed JR Mudassir Husain, Justice Mohammad Ruhul Amin, Justice MM Ruhul Amin, Justice Tafazzal Isalm and Justice Amirul Kabir Chowdhury.
The order came on a contempt petition filed by Barrister M Amir-ul Islam, intervener of the Masdar Hossain case, on behalf of Chowdhury Munir Uddin Mahfuz, presiding judge of Shishu-O-Nari Nirjaton Daman Ain Tribunal of Kishoreganj, one of the petitioners of the original writ petition in this case.
Hearing of the contempt petition was held Sunday.
A fresh contempt petition was filed, on March 1, in the Supreme Court against 10 top bureaucrats for 'violating at different times' the 12-point directives of the Supreme Court in the judgment of the separation of the judiciary case popularly known as Masdar Hossain case.
The 10 bureaucrats are - Prime Minister's Principal Secretary Dr Kamal Uddin Siddiqui, Law Secretary Alauddin Sarder and its former Secretaries Asaduzzaman and Justice Afzal Hossain Ahmed, Establishment Secretary Dr Mahbubur Rahman and its former Secretaries ASM Abdul Halim (Currently Cabinet secretary), Safarraj Hossain (Currently Home Secretary) and Anwarul Bar Chowdhury, Finance Secretary Siddiqur Rahman and its former Secretary Zakir Ahmed Khan.
During the delivering of the order Monday morning, nine bureaucrats against whom a contempt rule has already been issued on charge of distorting the judgment of Masdar Hossain case appeared in persons before the full bench of Appellate Division.
The accused government officials are- Joint Secretaries of Establishment Ministry Lokman Hakim, Badrul Alam Tarafdar and Md Abdur Rab Hawlader, Deputy Secretary Md Abul Kalam Chowdhury and Senior Assistant Secretary Md Khalilur Rahman, Deputy Secretary of the Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Ministry Shafiqul Islam Talukder and Senior Assistant Secretary Mohammad Harun-ur Rashid, and Deputy Secretaries of the Cabinet Division Md Fazlul Huq and Finance Ministry AKM Motaleb Hossain.
They will have to appear in persons before the Chief Justice's court on the day for next hearing in the case, since the apex court did not exempt them from personal appearance before the court.
After issuance of the order, Dr Kamal Hossain, who has been moving the case as an intervener, told reporters that the SC has discharged its constitutional duties to implement its judgment through issuing the contempt rule against the four secretaries.
"As the apex court of the country, the Supreme Court's constitutional responsibility is to protect its supremacy, dignity and image, and the Supreme Court has done it," he said.
Barrister M Amir-ul Islam, also the president of the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA), said the government has resorted to a dilly-dally tactics by playing fraud upon the court in complying with the Supreme Court directives in the Masdar Hossain case for the last four years.
"The respondents of the case have been violating various orders of this court and delaying and frustrating the implementation process of the judgment and grossly violating the directives of the judgment by way of misinterpretation, trickery and willful insubordination in perverse and manipulative manner," he said.
The Supreme Court with patience has several times given time to the government to comply with the directives but the government did not implement the judgment.
Following a writ petition filed in 1995 by 406 petitioners, including Masdar Hossain and Chowdhury Munir Uddin Mahfuz, the then leaders of BCS Judicial Association, the High Court on December 2, 1999, passed an order with 12-point directives to separate the judiciary from the executive.
In the review judgment of the case, the Appellate Division, on June 18, 2001, upheld the directives.
So far, the government sought extensions for 22 times to comply with the 12-point directives of the Supreme Court for separating the judiciary from the executive.
The Supreme Court, on October 20, 2005, had refused to entertain a government petition seeking another four months' time for separating the judiciary from the executive as per the Supreme Court's 12-point directives.
Barrister Rokanudin Mahmud, Advocate M Enayetur Rahim, Barrister Tania Amir, advocate Manzill Murshid Barrister Tanjib-ul Alam, Barrister Monruzzaman Asad, Barrister Sarah Hossain, Barrister Moyeen Firoz and Barrister Shamsul Alam Hasan assisted Dr Kamal Hossain and Barrister M Amir-ul Islam in moving the case before the court, while attorney general AJ Mohammad Ali, Additional Attorney Generals -Abdur Razzak Khan and Fida M Kamal for the state, and Advocate TH Khan and advocate Khondker Mahbubuddin Ahmed for the nine accused government officials.
BDNEWS/1520 hrs