S Q Chy continues with his antics
BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury continued with his theatrics when prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum approached the war crimes tribunal to initiate contempt proceedings against another BNP leader M K Anwar.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
04 Apr 2012, 11:09 AM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:37 PM
Tanim Ahmed
Dhaka, Apr 4 (bdnews24.com) — BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury continued with his theatrics when prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum approached the war crimes tribunal to initiate contempt proceedings against another BNP leader M K Anwar.
The BNP policymaker expressed his disappointment when the International Crimes Tribunal-1 — set up to deal with the crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War — declined to take any action against M K Anwar, a former agriculture minister of the BNP-led government.
He said he was fully 'supporting Mr Malum' on this issue.
Prosecutor Malum had said during his submissions that Anwar was deliberately making comments about the tribunal proceedings to impede the trial which warranted the court's contempt.
He referred to reports of three newspapers that quoted the former agriculture minister, also a current BNP policymaker, saying that the tribunal had shown an instance of "jungle law" by accepting statements of 15 witnesses given to the investigation officer as evidence.
The prosecutor quoted Anwar as saying that this was not acceptable under the Criminal Procedure Code. Malum added the former civil servant was making these statements with full knowledge of the fact and suggested that the opposition leader had ulterior motives.
Justice Huq said it seemed to him that M K Anwar could not get the CrPC or the Evidence Act out of his head. "If well educated people like him make such comments, it is very unfortunate."
Salauddin Quader, who was back in the dock after lunch since the court would hear his petitions after disposing of the prosecution's pleas, kept on with his quips in between Justice Huq's statements, saying, "Absolutely ignorant…they know nothing at all!"
Justice Huq said before making any comments one should understand the matter. Referring to the situation at hand he asked Malum in apparent exasperation, "What can we do?"
The BNP leader was up on his feet at the opportunity to suggest a measure. "Put him in jail! Put him in jail, sir! It is getting very lonely."
Justice Huq continued to say, "People can criticise the laws but they cannot question the integrity or neutrality of the tribunal."
Salauddin Quader: Absolutely right. You are saying that CrPC and Evidence Act are not applicable here according to the law (International Crimes Tribunal Act 1973). That is quite the jungle law! But a jungle law will give rise to a jungle court, that is not 100 percent correct.
The politician's antics even had the judges smile. But Salauddin Quader continued with his feigned earnestness. "You see all my friends have this bad habit. Just read sir what my other friend Surnjit Sengupta has said."
Justice Huq could not but admit at this point that the accused never failed to entertain him. "Mr Chowdhury, we quite enjoy your deliberations here."
SQ Chowhdury: So do I sir, so do I!
Justice Huq then passed an order saying that the tribunal would expect people to read the law before making observations about the tribunal proceedings.
Regarding M K Anwar, a member of BNP standing committee as Salauddin Quader is, the judge observed that this man was a former minister, a former cabinet secretary, a former deputy commissioner and a magistrate.
Anwar had risen through the ranks of civil bureaucracy before joining politics and it was that past that the tribunal referred to for pointing out that this man obviously had an understanding of laws.
Justice Huq in his order stated that Anwar must have been swayed by his sentiments when he made the statement but the tribunal believed that he had not read the law.
"But if he has then we can only say 'sorry'." The judge continued to state that the tribunal expected people like Anwar and others like him would cooperate so that there may be a fair trial with the help of all.
"This is unexpected, but we do not find anything that calls for action under section 11.4 (of the ICTA)."
The tribunal said, "We expect people to read this law before making any comment on the trial procedures of the tribunal."
No sooner had Justice Huq concluded than Salauddin Quader exploded again.
"No no, this is far too less! By the tribunal's standards this is far too little. I was completely with Mr Malum on this one."
Section 11.4 of the 1973 Act states, "A Tribunal may punish any person, who obstructs or abuses its process or disobeys any of its orders or directions, or does anything which tends to prejudice the case of a party before it, or tends to bring it or any of its members into hatred or contempt, or does anything which constitutes contempt of the Tribunal, with simple imprisonment which may extend to one year, or with fine which may extend to Taka five thousand, or with both."
Section 19.2 of the same states, "A Tribunal may receive in evidence any statement recorded by a Magistrate or an Investigation Officer being a statement made by any person who, at the time of the trial, is dead or whose attendance cannot be procured without an amount of delay or expense which the Tribunal considers unreasonable."
It was under this provision that the tribunal agreed to receive — not accept, as categorically pointed out by a tribunal member — as evidence the statements of 15 witnesses against Jamaat-e-Islami executive council member Delwar Hossain Sayedee.
The order also stated the tribunal would keep it in mind that these witnesses had not been cross-examined, suggesting that this evidence would not have similar weight as that coming from the witnesses who were produced before the court and cross-examined by the defence.
The tribunal later fixed Apr 12 as the date for hearing several more applications of Salauddin Quader after his counsel Fakhrul Islam repeatedly attempted to argue several petitions but was shot down by the tribunal.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1643h