Quader Molla's defence to know it Sunday
The defence appeals to tribunal for a copy of the investigation report, which the prosecution intensely opposes
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
16 Jan 2012, 12:58 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:18 PM
Dhaka, Jan 16 (bdnews24.com) — The war crimes tribunal will rule on next Sunday whether the defence will be provided with the investigation report in Jamaat-e-Islami leader Abdul Quader Molla's case.
M Tajul Islam and Mizanul Islam argued for the defence. Tajul Islam citing certain provisions of the International Crimes Tribunal Act of 1973 and its rules of procedure submitted that the tribunal was required to consider the investigation report along with the formal charge when framing charges.
The prosecution submits a formal charge once the investigation agency submits its investigation in a certain case, both of which are submitted to the tribunal.
The relevant section of the law states, "A copy of the formal charge and a copy of each of the documents lodged with the formal charge shall be furnished to the accused person at a reasonable time before the trial; and in case of any difficulty in furnishing copies of the documents, reasonable opportunity for inspection shall be given to the accused person in such manner as the Tribunal may decide."
The laws also stipulate that the prosecution submit the investigation report, witness testimonies, list of witnesses and other necessary documents with its formal charge.
Tajul Islam said according to its own rules and laws the tribunal is bound to consider the investigation report, among other documents, when taking cognisance of the charges and also when framing charges.
Tajul Islam also pointed out that the laws clearly state that the defence would be furnished with copies of all documents lodged by the prosecution along with their formal charge.
He said this crucial piece of document was necessary for the defence to prepare accordingly. "Not furnishing the defence with the investigation report would irreparably damage the defence's case."
The counsel also said that making it available to the defence would in no way prejudice the case against the prosecution.
Prosecutor Mohammad Ali stated that nowhere in the laws or the rules is it mentioned that the defence be provided with a copy of the investigation report, which he suggested was solely for the consumption of the prosecution and the tribunal.
The prosecution also suggested that since the laws stated 'investigation report' separately and then mentioned 'and other documents', the report would not fall under the category of a 'document' and hence was not required to be furnished to the defence.
Counsel Mizanul Islam then said that while it was true that there was no provision stipulating that the defence get a copy of the investigation report, there was no prohibition either.
He also pointed out that the tribunal may come back to the prosecution and defence when considering cognisance of charges. "At that point of time, how am I to defend myself if I do not know what is in the investigation report."
"If this is one of the documents that the tribunal will consider, then I must have access to this document," said Mizanul Islam.
He also dismissed the suggestion that the investigation report was not really a document.
Mizanul Islam also drew the attention of the tribunal to documents which would not be made available to the defence. The tribunal's rules of procedure state that the investigation officer will have to maintain a case diary, which might be used for refreshing the memory for certain details if needed.
Islam cited section 8.3 of the rules of procedure pointing out that it was explicitly said that the defence would have no right to examine this case diary and went on that there was no such prohibition as regards the investigation report.
He also pointed out that the tribunal using its 'inherent powers' to meet the ends of justice did provide the defence with certain documents and records regarding which there are no clear directions in the act or the rules. He urged the tribunal to make provisions for the defence to receive copies of the investigation reports in the same vein.
At this point the tribunal addressed the prosecution and asked what the problem was with providing the investigation report to the defence and asked about the rules of procedure.
Mohammad Ali referred to section 14 of the rules of procedure which, he said, stipulated the prosecution and investigation agency to ensure confidentiality of information.
It states, "The Prosecution and the Investigation Agency shall take necessary measures to ensure the confidentiality of any information, the protection of any witness or victim and the preservation of all the evidence collected."
He then said that the investigation report had names, particulars and addresses of witness and victims which would jeopardise the prosecution's case were it to be divulged to the defence.
The prosecutor said that the investigation report contained all such details and thus could not be provided to the defence for the sake of security and confidentiality of the witnesses and victims.
Tajul Islam said the tribunal could then easily order that the compromising details be deleted before making the report available to the defence.
Tribunal chairman Justice Nizamul Huq then said that the order in this regard would be given next Sunday
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1854h