November 21, 2026

Orders on SQ Chy pleas on Mar 13

War crimes tribunal defers indictment hearings of Quader Molla to Tuesday and Nizami to Wednesday. Full story, more quotes

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 05 Mar 2012, 11:53 AM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 03:30 PM

Dhaka, Mar 5 (bdnews24.com)—The war crimes tribunal will issue orders on all petitions filed by BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury on Mar 13. The International Crimes Tribunal, set up on Mar 25, 2010 to deal with the crimes against humanity during the 1971 Libertaion War, on Monday heard final arguments of Salauddin Quader's counsels Fakhrul Islam and Ahsanul Haq on a number of applications. The tribunal then fixed the next date when it will decide when to frame charges, provided that the BNP policymaker's discharge petition was rejected. The court also deferred indictment hearing of Jamaat-e-Islami assistant secretary general Abdul Quader Molla to Tuesday. Indictment hearing of the party's chief Matiur Rahman Nizami has also been pushed back to Wednesday. Ahsanul Haq began his arguments after the lunch recess noting that his counterpart from the prosecution, Zead-Al-Malum had spoken "magnificently" and at the same time managed to "say a great deal of nothing", failing to address any of the points raised by the defence. He prayed for an adjournment of seven to 10 days to ascertain the status of six cases that the prosecution had mentioned in its documents since that would amount to double jeopardy. The chief defence counsel also cited references in trying to answer a query of the tribunal relating to double jeopardy since the accused of the case had also had six cases filed against him for crimes that are apparently included in the formal charge. Article 35.2 of the constitution states, "No person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once." When the defence raised this point in relation to the supposedly six pending cases, three under the penal and three under the collaborators' act (there was a correction, although the counsels had initially said all six were under the collaborators act of 1972 which bars cases to be transferred elsewhere), Justice Nizamul Huq had asked Ahsanul Haq what the "and" of 'prosecuted and punished' meant. Ahsanul Haq cited Bindra's Interpretation of the Statutes, so named after a renowned lawyer of the Indian Supreme Court, and submitted that the "and" could be taken as "or" when the intent of the legislation was clear. The engaging deliberations of Chittagong MP's chief counsel were interrupted once by prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum who said that Haq was merely killing time. "Whatever he is saying is for the consumption of the media." Justice Huq disagreed, saying that the counsels only addressed the court and the journalists only made notes of the proceedings but nothing was said addressing them. Once Malum had taken his seat, Ahsanul Haq chose to engage the entire court with a few quips. First he addressed the court, saying that he understood it was a matter of courtesy not to interrupt when a counsel was submitting before the court. "Perhaps it would be better if there were no such insinuations as 'wasting time' in future." He then told the judges that he sought refuge from the court to save him from such interruptions. "I am an old man and Mr Malum is a larger than me in size." Haq then turned his head from podium looking at Malum as if measuring the imposing figure of the prosecutor. He turned back his head as if reassured that Malum's physical prowess was more than his, and said, "You see if he tells me not to come to the court from tomorrow, it may well turn out that I actually won't dare to." The entire court, including the judges, found the exchange rather hilarious. Prosecutor Malum managed to ruffle a few feathers as soon as he took the podium to reply when he said, "We are constantly under the whip of the tribunal." Justice Huq asked, "Do you mean that for both the prosecution and the defence?" Malum: No just the prosecution. Justice Huq: No you can't say that (with serious shake of the head). Malum: No my lord, we are. The tribunal chairman did not want to take it any further but showed his firm disagreement. Prosecutor Malum said that provision of the constitution did not apply to the tribunal since "this is a constitutional matter and this court cannot go beyond its law". Malum stuck to his point although tribunal member, Judge A K M Zaheer Ahmed pointed out, "This is not a question of interpreting the constitution." The prosecutor said the constitutional provision would not apply to this case. When asked about the status of a specific case that had been lodged against Saluddin Quader Chowdhury before, Malum proceeded to read out the order of a writ petition although that still left judge's question unanswered. He said it was still "pending", but when the tribunal probed further Malum said the fate was "unknown". Malum then said that the prosecution could still submit its response and the legally that time limit had not expired. The petitions that will be up for order at the tribunal on Mar 13 include one for bail, a discharge petition with additional grounds, a review petition to adhere to international covenants and standards, a bail petition, a petition for release citing arbitrary detention and another for jail transfer. Earlier, before lunch, the tribunal told Salauddin Quader's another counsel, Fakhrul Islam, to wrap up arguments several times as he stumbled along apparently lingering his submissions. Fakhrul Islam was replying to certain queries in support of his second discharge petition but appeared to stumble for words as well as legal points through the last half hour as the tribunal sat silently for minutes together. Tribunal member Justice A T M Fazle Kabir chose to speak during one of those periods when Fakhrul Islam went mum, "We have heard these submissions you are making. You seem to be repeating yourself." Prosecutor Malum seized the opportunity and said, "We would love to hear his profound thoughts but he must also bear the amount of time he is taking." Tribunal chairman, Justice Nizamul Huq said, "We have cautioned him that he is replying to our questions." Fakhrul Islam then tried to make a point about whom the prosecution represented since it was appointed by the government and brought to the court's attention that a prosecutor had said he represented the martyr's families. Islam wondered which martyr. "Each and every martyr," replied Justice Huq with a finality precluding further argument on the matter. Fakhrul Islam lapsed into another one of his reveries soon afterwards, when Justice Kabir urged him to conclude quickly. However, Fakhrul Islam refused to leave the podium and insisted that he had one or two more points to make although he did not appear to remember them then. The prosecution submitted formal charges against Salauddin Quader on Nov 14, 2011 and the tribunal took them into cognisance three days later. The Chittagong MP was shown arrested for war crimes charges on Dec 20, 2010 five days after his arrest. The investigating agency submitted a 119-page report with around 8,000-page data report to the chief prosecutor on Oct 3 in a bid to prove allegations of war crimes during the 1971 Liberation War. Besides Jamaat executive council member Delwar Hossain Sayedee whose case is the most advanced, Jamaat chief Matiur Rahman Nizami, secretary general Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla, and Bangladesh Nationalist Party's standing committee member and MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury have been detained on war crimes charges. The tribunal has also sent Jamaat-e-Islami's former chief Ghulam Azam to jail on Jan 11. The second part of his formal charge hearing was held on Feb 27 when the prosecution played out some video clips. The prosecution is expected to place its arguments in support of the formal charges on Tuesday when the tribunal is also expected to begin indictment hearing against Jamaat assistant secretary general Abdul Quader Molla. Molla, however, is not required to be present due to severe back pain as petitioned by his counsel M Tajul Islam. The tribunal granted conditional bail to former BNP lawmaker and minister Abdul Alim on March 31 last year. The bail was extended further on Jan 16, ordering him to be present in the court on Mar 15 when the prosecution has been directed to submit formal charges against the BNP leader. bdnews24.com/ta/bd/2121h
Related Stories