Published :
11 Mar 2012, 11:17 AM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:32 PM
Dhaka, Mar 11 (bdnews24.com) – The High Court on Sunday issued a split verdict on a petition seeking orders against further obstruction to BNP's rally on Monday.
The bench of justices Mirza Hussain Haider and Muhammad Khurshid Alam Sarker heard the plea filed by Supreme Court lawyer Ruhul Quddus Kajal.
Senior judge of the bench, Justice Haider, issued a rule at 2pm but Justice Sarker dismissed the appeal.
The chief justice will now hear the petition in line with rules. But lawyers said he will send it to a third bench for hearing.
Supreme Court Bar Association president Khandker Mahbub Hossain argued the case for the petitioner while attorney general Mahbubey Alam opposed it.
The home secretary, inspector general of police and Dhaka Metropolitan Police commissioner were made defendants in the petition.
Justice Haider in his rule asked them why an order should not be issued to ensure fundamental rights of citizens, especially supporters and activists of BNP and its associate organisations, in line with Sections 27, 31, 32, 33, 36, 37, 38, 39 and 43 of the constitution.
He asked them to respond within six weeks.
The BNP has been saying that police are detaining its leaders and activists across the country ahead of the rally.
The law-enforcers have also been accused by the opposition of pressing bus operators, hotels and guesthouses in the city to suspend services to foil the rally.
Plaintiff Kajal sought High Court's direction to release and compensate the BNP activists detained without due legal process in the run-up to the public gathering at Naya Paltan.
He also sought a direction to facilitate the staging of the rally without hindrance.
"The split verdict put question marks over the rule of law. It is a glaring example as to what extent the judiciary has been politicised," said Mahbub Hossain.
"We have learned from reports published in different national newspapers that people are being prevented from coming to the capital. The senior judge (of the bench) thinks it relates to violation of people's constitutional rights," he added.
"We have come here with the issues relating to violation of people's fundamental rights. But we see that the judiciary is not working properly either," the SCBA chief continued.
Attorney general Mahbubey Alam censured the statements of Mahbub Hossain and said these were tantamount to contempt of court since judged were constitutionally entitled to agree or differ independently.
"It has been said in the writ petition that BNP leaders and activists are being prevented from joining the rally and the action has violated their fundamental rights. Writ petitions regarding people's fundamental rights cannot be filed on such generalised statement. It has to be on some specific incidents," said Alam.
"Trial of war criminals is going on and [Harkat-ul-Jihad-al-Islami, Bangladesh] is till active. Who will ensure that those people will not be coming to the rally? The government has to think about the security of people," he added.
Mahbub Hossain said, "Previously, we saw that justices did not differ over the verdict unless there was an interim order. The attorney general also did not go against it. But now the entire office of attorney general said that we filed the petition out of political intention."
"The movement that has its base among people does not require to go to court for its sustenance. The movements of Gandhi, Bangabandhu and Jahanara Imam are the classic examples," mentioned the attorney general.
bdnews24.com/sn/ost/eh/bd/1841h