November 21, 2026

Ghulam Azam defence seeks retrial

Contents of an alleged Skype conversation between former ICT-1 Chairman Justice Nizamul Huq and a Brussels-based academic continue to rule war crimes proceedings.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 24 Dec 2012, 03:58 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:36 PM

Contents of an alleged Skype conversation between former International Crimes Tribunal-1 Chairman Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq and a Brussels-based academic continue to rule war crimes proceedings.

The Jamaat-e-Islami's chief counsel on Monday presented, what he said was, only the "tip of the iceberg" while moving an application seeking retrial of the party's former chief Ghulam Azam at the first war crimes tribunal.

Abdur Razzaq said he would present "facts" from over 17 hours of the alleged conversation and a few hundred emails supposedly between Justice Huq and the international law expert, Ahmed Ziauddin.

Also an Assistant Secretary General of Jamaat, Razzaq presented hundreds of pages of email screenshots of a gmail inbox bearing an address that corresponds to the former chairman's initials.

The defence counsel also presented parts of the alleged conversation over the internet claimed to have been transcribed verbatim and published by the daily Amar Desh, a BNP-leaning newspaper headed by a former energy advisor of the 2001-06 BNP government.

Attorney General Mahbubey Alam's intervention, saying that there was a court ban on referring to the alleged conversation, failed to prevent the Jamaat defence counsel from referring to contents of exchange between Justice Huq and Ziauddin.

The top law officer for the government said referring to the Jamaat counsel at the podium, "He can very well move his application, but without referring to the contents."

This was followed by stifled laughter from the left half of the court where the defence counsels are generally seated. Abdur Razzaq, however, was quick to raise a hand and hush them, lest they irritate the court.

The Jamaat counsel meticulously took the tribunal through the material in an attempt to show that the tribunal under Justice Huq had been influenced by "a man sitting in Brussels".

He showed emails — taken from the inbox of the gmail account that is said to have belonged to Justice Huq — which contained certain orders that the tribunal delivered.

Razzaq said that the order whereby the tribunal took cognisance of the charges against Ghulam Azam's, and the one that indicted the former Jamaat chief had been received by Justice Huq.

According to Razzaq, the former tribunal chief then copied those orders, often word for word, and presented them to his members as his order. "The honourable chairman committed fraud upon the court."

"And on this point alone, the case cannot proceed."

The counsel's deliberations were replete with phrases like 'the order originated note here but thousands of mile away' or 'the tribunal passed orders written by a man sitting far away in Brussels'.

Razzaq began his deliberation saying that he was moving the application with a "heavy heart" because it would show "how the prestige of this court, how the honour of this court have been brought down".

The defence counsel proceeded to show that the text in the emails corresponded with those of the orders, often verbatim and furthermore that orders were typically received from one Ahmed Ziauddin via email a day or two before it was given out by the tribunal.

The defence counsel said, together with the emails and Skype conversations, the contents clearly showed that the tribunal had lost its independence in the exercise of its judicial function.

He was still going on at around 4pm and asked for the court's leave to stop.

Tribunal chairman A T M Fazle Kabir, who was transferred to the first tribunal after Justice Huq's resignation, replied, "But your argument is all but done!"

"I have not even begun, your lordship," Razzaq replied quickly.

The tribunal then adjourned for the day and is expected to resume hearing the defence on Wednesday.

The so-called Skype controversy first came to light on Dec 6 through an order of the former Chairman Justice Huq himself where he admitted that he did take the assistance of one Ahmed Ziauddin living in Brussels.

It also came to light that the UK-based 'The Economist' had called the judge claiming to be in possession of over 17 hours of Skype conversations and hundreds of emails between Justice Huq and Ahmed Ziauddin.

The court's order that day directed the British journal to not publish the contents of those illegally procured material and directed its authorities to reply why measures should not be taken against them.

The daily Amar Desh began publishing, what it suggested, transcripts of conversation that the judge had with his acquaintance in Belgium from Dec 9 and continued for the next four days which gave rise to a huge controversy.

The tribunal Chairman resigned from his position on Dec 11 and Justice Kabir, then heading the second tribunal, was appointed as head of the first tribunal where he had served as a member until establishment of the second tribunal in March this year.

Just before adjourning the proceedings for the day, Justice Kabir said addressing asked Razzaq, "One thing is not clear. [Justice Huq] admitted to talking to Ahmed Ziauddin, but has he admitted to these contents? Has he admitted that he has indeed had this conversation?"

The defence counsel reiterated the same point that he had made during his deliberations earlier — that there were no rejoinders or denials on the part of the judge. To the question at hand, Razzaq replied, "But has he not read Amar Desh or the Economist? Couldn't he have said that it was not his statement?"

The defence counsel then also offered to play out the voice recordings only to reassure the tribunal by the sound of the judge's voice if the CDs were played out.

The chairman then adjourned proceedings untilDec 26.

Related Stories