November 21, 2026

Defence irks war crimes tribunal

A defence counsel's brash behaviour angers the war crimes tribunal chairman.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 08 Apr 2012, 05:02 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 03:38 PM

Dhaka, Apr 8 (bdnews24.com) — Defence counsel M Tajul Islam's brash behaviour angered the war crimes tribunal chairman so much that at one point of a heated conversation, the judge got carried away to the extent of saying that he would not do justice. The International Crimes Tribunal – 1, set up on Mar 25, 2010 to deal with crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, indicted Jamaat-e-Islami executive council member Delwar Hossain Sayedee on Oct 3 on 20 counts of crimes against humanity including murder, rape, arson and loot. Sunday was scheduled for the deposition of investigation officer Mohammad Helaluddin. The entire matter had stemmed from the inconsistency of prosecution documents with different sets having different page numbers. It was at a point during Helaluddin's deposition when he was referring to Sayedee as a listed Razakar, a vigilante group mobilised essentially by the Jamaat-e-Islami and its student wing Islami Chhatra Sangha during 1971. The Razakars, as well as other similar militia groups like the Al Badr and the Al Shams, were notorious for the kind of atrocities they committed across the country in their efforts to thwart the Liberation War and its supporters. The reference, prosecutor Syed Haider Ali, said would be found on page 3521, whereas the tribunal chief, Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq said it was on 3510. The defence said it was on page 3512 according to their set of documents. At this point defence counsel Mizanul Islam pointed out to the tribunal in his characteristically tempered manner that since three sets of documents were different then it would naturally pose a problem during arguments and submissions since they would have to refer to the page numbers that correspond with the judges' sets of documents. The tribunal chief, Justice Huq agreed. The defence counsel wondered what could be done about it to which the tribunal chairman casually remarked, "Well, have them corrected then." Mizanul Islam said that it was merely a clerical exercise and not that the defence would be hard pressed to make the corrections. "But the prosecution should have provided sets that did correspond with each other." The chief prosecutor, Ghulam Arieff Tipoo, a senior lawyer of Rajshahi Bar where he had virtually seen Mizanul Islam grow up as a lawyer, told him from across the aisle, "So there are some mistakes. Have them corrected and it will be taken care of." M Tajul Islam, who typically presents a stark contrast to his colleague Mizanul Islam retorted at the comment. "What do you mean, have them corrected? Am I a lacquey?" He went on to address the court regarding the anomaly, but could not get very far in his belligerent tone. Justice Huq told him to restrain himself. "There is a manner of speaking. You see Mizanul Islam speaks and you also speak," said the tribunal chairman implying the obvious difference in their style of delivery. Tajul Islam: No two people will speak in a same tone. It is only natural that there will be a difference between people. Justice Huq: I am telling to you to restrain yourself. Take it as an advice from an elder brother. Restraint is sought for. You are not a junior lawyer anymore. The tribunal chief was trying to explain that since this was the first case and since everyone was new the prosecution had not been able to provide documents in the right order and they naturally needed to be corrected. However, Tajul Islam would not stop either and kept talking as well. This irritated the judge and he said, "What is the matter? You keep talking!" But Tajul Islam was hardly deterred and quite on the verge of shouting. The tribunal chairman said almost as loudly, "You mean to say that the tribunal overlooks the prosecution's omissions but those of the defence. Isn't that what you want to say? Fine, go on, say it." Tajul Islam still refused to relent as his colleagues, Tanvir Ahmed Al-Amin and Mizanul Islam, tugged at his robe to make him sit down and not irk the judge further. When the defence counsel tried to suggest that this would be illegal and the tribunal must do justice, the judge retorted back, "Fine I won't do justice. Happy?" That remark finally shut Tajul Islam up and he sat down. Mizanul Islam took up the matter, and asked for permission of the court to speak. Justice Huq vented a little more, "It does not seem the permission is needed. People stand up whenever they feel like and say whatever they feel like." In his attempt to cool things down, the defence counsel said, "The anomaly in page numbers was not desired, neither was the comment from the chief prosecutor and nor the reaction that eventually came from the court." Justice Huq had cooled down a little by then. He said, "I agree." When later asked, Tajul Islam declined to comment on the judge's reaction and told the press that the journalists were in the courtroom and had seen and heard what went on. bdnews24.com/ta/sk/2245h
Related Stories