November 21, 2026

Debate over democracy descends into disorder

The inaugural session of a seminar on democracy descended into disorder for quite a while Saturday following a debate involving the law minister and practice of democracy, veering from its topic track.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 18 Aug 2006, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 06:33 PM

Dhaka, August 19 (BDNEWS) – The inaugural session of a seminar on democracy descended into disorder for quite a while Saturday following a debate involving the law minister and practice of democracy, veering from its topic track. The seminar titled 'Practice of Democracy: Importance of Free and Fair Elections in Bangladesh' organised jointly by Bangladesh Institute of Law and International Affairs (BILIA), Bangladesh Heritage Foundation, Human Rights Research and Democracy and Citizens Council for South Asian Solidarity at a Gulshan hotel in Dhaka with Justice KM Sobhan in the chair. The chaos started when chairman of the editorial board of the Daily Ittefaq Barrister Mainul Hosein objected part of keynote paper and asked the chair to stop the presenter, Ambassador Wali-ur Rahman, terming the content irrelevant to the seminar topic. The chaos turned a pandemonium later when the law minister and some of audience were locked in an altercation as the minister asked the chair to permit him to speak earlier than the schedule. Moudud said that he would not stay long at the seminar because of some urgent piece of business. "You should not do this... this is not democracy that you'll make us listen to you but you will not listen to us," an agitated member from the audience shouted out loud pulling support from many others. At one stage, defending himself Moudud said, "Democracy doesn't mean you can butt-in while I am speaking as you have done." Afterwards interference by the others brought the seminar back on track. But many were found whispering that the minister's attitude turned the situation disgraceful for the image of country's democratic practice in front of foreign delegates and donor agency representatives present at the seminar. In his speech, law minister Moudud Ahmed, MP, said that all the institutions and pre-conditions required for good governance, fair elections, parliamentary government system, independent judiciary and media, vibrant private sector—were there in Bangladesh. "The challenges are to improve the standard of these institutions and as it is not possible overnight, everyone has to try concertedly," he said adding that as democracy here was established after two spells of martial law, it needed to be nurtured by forgetting the past bitterness. Before leaving the venue just after his speech, Moudud placed three suggestions for good governance: ensuring neutrality of the Speaker, making the parliamentary standing committees effective and providing the opposition with the scope for playing due role in the Sangsad. In his speech, Abdul Jalil, MP, general secretary of the opposition Awami League, criticised the law minister's claim of independent judiciary saying, "In recent days, we saw that High Court verdicts were available according to the wishes of the government." Jalil slammed the foreign interference in Bangladesh politics and in electoral procedure. Referring to the Local Consultative Group (LCG), he raised an allegation that in the name of election monitoring, anti-people forces backed by foreign funding intruded in Bangladesh. He said, "We will not accept the so-called fair elections certified by the foreign forces." Jalil also called for an impartial Speaker who should be removed from the party politics after selection to the constitutional post. Barrister Mainul Hosein criticised the opposition for setting pre-conditions for dialogue saying, it's ridiculous that a political party wants its rival party to materialise its demands. "Why should the government implement the demands of the opposition? They (the opposition) should do that assuming power through elections." Among others, AL presidium member Suranjit Sengupta, AL leader Saber Hossain Chowdhury, economist of Research and Development Centre Forrest E. Cookson and National Democracy Institute (NDI) representative Owen Lippert also spoke. BDNEWS/1913
Related Stories