Published : 08 Mar 2022, 10:40 AM
Updated : 03 Aug 2022, 11:36 AM
“For better or worse,” he wrote, “more Americans respond to evocations of toughness in the face of a threat.”
The label caught on — and “climate hawk” has since become a badge worn proudly by a nucleus of politically savvy climate-action advocates. And now, days into Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, leading climate hawks sense that the moment is ripe to connect the war to their cause.
“America is lining Putin’s pockets by buying billions of dollars of Russian oil,” said Sen Ed Markey and an architect of the Green New Deal. “The United States doesn’t need Russian oil any more than we need Russian caviar.”
Adding to the feeling of urgency: As the war began, a United Nations climate panel issued a landmark report detailing the catastrophic effects of global warming, which include floods, deadly heat waves and extreme water scarcity that could affect millions.
“This whole crisis points out the need for us to wean ourselves and the rest of the world off fossil fuels,” said Tom Steyer, a billionaire former presidential candidate and major Democratic donor.
The climate hawks are in temporary alignment with foreign policy hawks, who also worry about importing oil and gas from unstable and undemocratic parts of the world — but for different reasons. The two groups agree on cutting off Putin’s energy lifeline, but that’s about it. And it’s not clear which way the Biden administration, with gasoline prices surging past $4 a gallon, will go.
There are various ideas floating around Capitol Hill for cutting off imports of Russian energy, all of which got a boost Monday when lawmakers agreed on a legislative framework to do so.
What happens next is where the agreement starts to break down. To vastly oversimplify, Capitol Hill divides into two basic camps on how to replace the Russian oil.
On one side is a bipartisan group led by two senators from fossil fuel-producing states: Joe Manchin III and Lisa Murkowski, who have recruited Republicans and many moderate Democrats to their bill implementing the Russian cutoff.
On the other side are the climate hawks: Markey, Sen Martin Heinrich and many progressive Democrats in the House. Last week, Markey and Heinrich unveiled their alternate proposal for banning Russian energy imports: the SPIGOT (Severing Putin’s Immense Gains from Oil Transfers) Act. Unlike Manchin and Murkowski’s legislation, their bill requires the US to replace Russian imports with renewable energy over time.
Some quirkier ideas have emerged. Bill McKibben, an activist close to the administration, is calling on President Joe Biden to use the Defence Production Act to ramp up the manufacture of heat pumps — highly energy-efficient, all-in-one heating and cooling units — and ship them to Europe.
“We could peacefully punch Putin in the kidneys,” McKibben wrote in his Substack newsletter.
WHITE HOUSES’S DILEMMA
The president has stacked his administration with climate hawks, and has put forward ambitious policies to rein in carbon emissions and move the country toward renewable, clean energy.
But Ukraine’s crisis is testing that.
White House officials say that over the long run, the world needs to move past fossil fuels. But, with oil prices already touching $130 a barrel, they don’t want to further roil the markets.
So, administration officials are scouring the world to replace Russia’s oil output. There are no easy choices: Iran (which is under economic sanctions), Venezuela (also under sanctions) and Saudi Arabia (which is angry with the US for various reasons) have been floated as possibilities.
But as he worries about gas prices, Biden also has to worry about the left. Progressives criticised him last week for saying little about climate change in his State of the Union address. The bulk of his climate agenda was blocked when Manchin and Sen Kyrsten Sinema, torpedoed the Build Back Better Act, Democrats’ social policy bill. Democrats fear that could leave young voters who turned out for Biden in 2020 demoralized in 2022.
REPUBLICANS’ SQUEEZE PLAY
Even as Republicans urge the president to stop importing Russian energy, they’re redoubling their political messaging blaming him for high gasoline prices. And they’re demanding for him to “unleash” energy production in the United States.
Republicans’ arguments are hollow, experts tell us. The surge in global economic activity as the coronavirus pandemic ebbs is the main factor driving up gasoline prices, not Biden’s energy policies. Domestic production of crude oil actually increased in 2021. The limits Biden has placed on drilling on federal lands don’t affect current production. And, as White House officials have pointed out, the industry is sitting on thousands of unused drilling permits.
Allies of the administration note, too, that even though Russia may be a minor supplier for the US, it exports around 5 million barrels of crude oil a day. Because oil prices are set globally, taking all of that off the market would send prices soaring.
“People think presidents have more control over the price of oil than they actually do,” said Samantha Gross, an energy analyst at the Brookings Institution.
THE POPULISTS PLUG IN
Politically, high oil prices are a nightmare. They make it difficult for Democrats to promote their stewardship of the economy.
Climate hawks propose a way out of this jam: Democrats should brand themselves as the party of future, not the past, they say. That means unapologetically embracing new technologies like electric vehicles while portraying oil as yesterday’s energy solution.
“Instead of ‘Drill, baby, drill,’ voters should hear: ‘Plug in, baby, plug in,’ ” Markey said.
Tom Matzzie, a former Washington campaign director for MoveOn.org, who now runs a company that builds solar farms, suggested Biden go after the oil companies.
“They’re trying to take advantage of the situation in Ukraine and pretend they have a solution when they don’t,” Matzzie said of the companies that are calling on Biden to repeal a moratorium on drilling on federal land.
Others worry that high oil prices will push Americans into embracing fossil fuels at the very moment they should be shifting away from them as fast as possible. Facing the prospect of disastrous midterm elections, Democrats could follow suit.
“Mixing up the difference between a short- and a long-term response would be an absolute failure for us intellectually,” Steyer said. “And a horrible decision for us as a country.”
© 2022 The New York Times Company