November 21, 2026

BNP sees discrepancies in verdict

Rafiqul Islam Mia sees incongruity between the short and full verdict that declared illegal the constitutional provision for caretakers.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 17 Sep 2012, 02:15 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:15 PM

Dhaka, Sep 15 (bdnews24.com) – BNP Standing Committee Member Rafiqul Islam Mia has said that there has been discrepancies between the short and full verdict of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court that declared illegal the constitutional provision for a non-party caretaker government system. The BNP leader at a function in the city on Monday said that the full bench of the Appellate Division, headed by the then Chief Justice, in the first part of its short verdict 16 months back had declared the 13th Amendment to the Constitution illegal. In the second part, he said that the court had said that the next two parliamentary elections might be held under the caretaker government for the interest of 'safety of the state and its people'. It also observed that Parliament might bring necessary amendments to the constitution so that the former chief justices or any other judges of the Appellate Division are not made head of the caretaker government, he said. "But there has been no mention of the issue in the full judgement. It has gone lost," he added. So it can 'easily be understood' that 'there is no contrast between the short verdict and the long-awaited full verdict of the Supreme Court invalidating the 13th amendment published on Sunday', he said. The BNP Standing Committee Member also said that there were questions whether the full verdict was trustworthy in view of law. He said that the full verdict has a 'connection' with the remarks of the Prime Minister regarding the termination of the 13th Amendment and the idea of the interim government during the polls. "This reveals that the chief of the government had knowledge about the verdict beforehand though the countrymen were unaware of it," he said. Rafiqul Islam Mia said that Justice Wahab Miah in the Section 49 of the full judgement observed that the next two general elections might be held under the caretaker government, but it is Parliament which will finally decide who will be the chief of the interim government. "But the full verdict lacks the mention of the caretaker government. We don't know the observations of the short verdict went lost." Also a lawyer, Rafiqul questioned the signature of former Chief Justice ABM Khairul Haque in the 342-page full judgement almost 16 months after the historic judgment that rescinded the caretaker government provision. "Except the sitting Chief Justice, no one can sign in any full verdict of the Supreme Court. So, it raises question whether the verdict terminating the 13th Amendment is the verdict of the Supreme Court. There's also uncertainty about the future of the verdict." The BNP leader was speaking at the inauguration of a token hunger strike programme organised by Swadhinata Forum, a pro-BNP platform, at National Press Club demanding whereabouts of the missing BNP leader M Ilias Ali. The full copy of the Supreme Court verdict, reached by a majority decision, eliminating the 13th Amendment was published on Sunday night. Former Chief Justice ABM Khairul Haque had signed the 342-page judgement in the Supreme Court on Thursday. He was the top judge who headed the seven-strong bench that delivered the verdict on May 10, 2011. Justices Mahmud Hossain, S K Sinha and Mozammel Hossain agreed with him. Justices Wahab Miah and Sultana differed while Justice Iman Ali left the matter for Parliament to decide. On June 30 last year, Parliament finally abolished the caretaker government system allowing general elections under elected partisan governments. The main opposition BNP has been opposing the constitutional amendment claiming that the government partly implemented the verdict, but overlooked the other part on two elections under the caretakers. According to the latest amendment to the constitution, the next parliamentary election will be held within 90 days before expiry of the tenure of the ruling Awami League-led Grand Alliance. It means the next parliamentary elections will be held sometime between November 2013 and January 2014. However, the BNP-led 18-Party Alliance has been demanding reinstatement of the caretaker government system saying that a free, fair and creditable election is not possible under a party-backed government. bdnews24.com/sm/ah/jk/skb/ano/1838h
Related Stories